Baltimore Orioles

Orioles manager Brandon Hyde ejected for arguing slide rule call in Patriots' Day matinee against Red Sox

Boston — Orioles manager Brandon Hyde was ejected from Monday’s Patriots’ Day matinee against the Boston Red Sox for arguing a slide-rule interpretation at second base after an unsuccessful replay review.

With runners on first and third and no outs in the fifth inning, Red Sox left fielder Steve Pearce hit a ground ball to third base. Rio Ruiz fielded it cleanly and relayed to second baseman Jonathan Villar.


Villar hesitated slightly before making the throw to first base as Rafael Devers appeared to slide through second base and stand up into Villar’s lower half. The throw to first was not in time, and Hyde thought a double play should have been awarded and the runner put back on third base instead of scoring the Red Sox’s first run.

“I just saw the runner slide past the base and not maintain contact with the base, and I've seen it called so many different ways, I just totally disagree with the ruling in New York,” Hyde said. “I understand that I'm going to get ejected. I just wanted clarity on how that's possible, if a guy slides past the base, doesn't maintain contact with the base, goes up into our fielder. If Villar's not there, he slides five feet past the base. Why isn't that a double play and the runner goes back to third base? I've had it called against us with the teams I've been with a few times, and I didn't understand the ruling today.”


According to MLB’s rule changes in 2016 meant to protect infielders on slides at second base, a slide is considered a “bona fide slide” and does not result in an automatic double play if it begins before the base, the runner is able to reach the base with his hand or foot, the runner attempts to stay on the base after completing the slide, and the runner doesn’t change his pathway to initiate contact.

The Orioles’ issue was apparently with the third clause.

After the review, Hyde went out to plead that case, even though he knew that arguing a replay call would only yield the response that it was the call of the league office in New York and there was nothing the four umpires on the field could do. Still, he continued to argue his case with first base umpire and crew chief Mark Wegner to the point of ejection. Hyde then went onto the infield to express his displeasure with second base umpire Jim Reynolds.

“If I argue that, I know I'm getting ejected,” Hyde said. “It's just one of those things ... those guys I really like. They just said there's nothing they can do and the ruling was in New York and they had to go with that. I didn't like the answer.”

It was Hyde’s second ejection as a coach and first coming as a manager, with his only other major league ejection last June 23 as the Chicago Cubs bench coach against the Cincinnati Reds.

Hyde’s was the second ejection of the series for the Orioles, as Stu Scheurwater ejected pitching coach Doug Brocail for arguing check-swing calls Sunday.

Major league field coordinator/catching instructor Tim Cossins took over managerial duties in the dugout after Hyde was thrown out, and made the pitching change in Hyde’s stead in the seventh inning. Hyde said after the game that he wasn’t doing it to fire the Orioles up, but instead to stand up for what he thought was right.

“I just felt like it was wrong,” Hyde said. “For me, they made a wrong decision, and I'm not just going to allow our team to just ... I just felt like the whole thing was wrong. I felt like it was handled [wrong], I just didn't agree with the decision in New York at all. If I disagree with something, I'll stand up for what I believe in. I don't believe that call was right. …

Baltimore Orioles Insider

Baltimore Orioles Insider


Want to be an Orioles Insider? The Sun has you covered. Don't miss any Orioles news, notes and info all baseball season and beyond.

“I'm going to get thrown out at times. I'm going to pick my spots, and I think when I disagree with something, then I'm going to let people know. Circumstances change, and in that type of situation, I go out there, I know I'm getting thrown out. But I really believe that it was the wrong call that was made.”

Karns back throwing

Hyde said the team should have a better idea of when right-hander Nate Karns, who is on the injured list with a right forearm strain, can return after they see him later this week.

Karns joined left-hander Richard Bleier (shoulder soreness) at the team's spring training facility in Sarasota this week, but they'll make the trip north to Tropicana Field to see the team's medical staff when the Orioles play the Rays beginning Tuesday.

"We're going to see him in Tampa," Hyde said. "He's doing his throwing progression, and he feels good. I think he's throwing a side here [with us] in the next couple of days, and we'll see how he looks after that, and see how he feels."

Outfielder Mark Trumbo (knee), who is also rehabilitating in Sarasota, Fla., will check in with the team in Tampa Bay as well.

The rotation going forward

Hyde said right-hander Alex Cobb (lumbar strain) will throw simulated game Tuesday at Tropicana Field, the success of which will determine if and when he can slot into the team's starting rotation this weekend when the team returns home to face the Minnesota Twins.


Dylan Bundy, David Hess and Andrew Cashner are the three scheduled Orioles starters for the three-game set with the first-place Rays. That would put left-hander John Means on track to start the series-opener against the Twins on Friday, but he’s pitched well enough that it’s no given he’s the one to cede his rotation spot for Cobb.