x-Eddie Murray 423
x-Gary Carter 387
Bruce Sutter 266
Jim Rice 259
Andre Dawson 248
Ryne Sandberg 244
Lee Smith 210
Rich Gossage 209
Bert Blyleven 145
Steve Garvey 138
Jim Kaat 130
Tommy John 116
Jack Morris 113
Alan Trammell 70
Don Mattingly 68
Dale Murphy 58
Dave Concepcion 55
Dave Parker 51
Fernando Valenzuela 31
Keith Hernandez 30
Darryl Kile 7
Vince Coleman 3
Brett Butler 2
Sid Fernandez 2
Rick Honeycutt 2
Tony Pena 2
Darren Daulton 1
Mark Davis 1
Danny Tartabull 1
Danny Jackson 0
Mickey Tettleton 0
Mitch Williams 0
Todd Worrell 0
(Kaat, Kile, Coleman, Butler, Fernandez, Honeycutt, Pena, Daulton, Davis, Tartabull, Jackson, Tettleton, Williams and Worrell are no longer eligible for election by the BBWAA.)
x-Gary Carter 387
Bruce Sutter 266
Jim Rice 259
Andre Dawson 248
Ryne Sandberg 244
Lee Smith 210
Rich Gossage 209
Bert Blyleven 145
Steve Garvey 138
Jim Kaat 130
Tommy John 116
Jack Morris 113
Alan Trammell 70
Don Mattingly 68
Dale Murphy 58
Dave Concepcion 55
Dave Parker 51
Fernando Valenzuela 31
Keith Hernandez 30
Darryl Kile 7
Vince Coleman 3
Brett Butler 2
Sid Fernandez 2
Rick Honeycutt 2
Tony Pena 2
Darren Daulton 1
Mark Davis 1
Danny Tartabull 1
Danny Jackson 0
Mickey Tettleton 0
Mitch Williams 0
Todd Worrell 0
(Kaat, Kile, Coleman, Butler, Fernandez, Honeycutt, Pena, Daulton, Davis, Tartabull, Jackson, Tettleton, Williams and Worrell are no longer eligible for election by the BBWAA.)