All things being equal, I'd take Santana. He's just a little more consistent. In four of his last six years, he has thrown 200-plus innings and had an ERA under 4.00. The other two seasons he was limited some by injuries. That said, Jimenez has a higher upside and is a little younger. I'd probably lean toward consistency, but, frankly, I'd consider either an upgrade for the Orioles rotation.