The Orange improved to 4-3, 2-0 Atlantic Coast Conference and the host Blue Devils fell to 8-2, 0-1.
Trimboli scored the game-winner in overtime, when then No. 6 Syracuse beat then-No. 11 Duke, 12-11 on March 25, 2017.
The win extended the Orange conference win streak to seven-straight games, dating back to the 2016 finale. The win also marks the 14th one-goal decision in the last-22 games for Syracuse, with a 12-2 record in such games.
Brendan Bomberry had a game-high four goals for the Orange. Joe Robertson and Brad Smith each had a hat trick for Duke.
Brendan Rooney, Jack Tigh and Ben Reeves each scored three goals for Yale. Jackson Morrill (McDonogh) had one goal and three assists.
No. 8 Villanova 13, Fairfield 12, OT: Danny Seibel scored the game-winner with 3:27 left in overtime to lift the host Wildcats (7-2) over the Stags (3-7). Fairfield's Dylan Beckwith tied the game with 56 seconds left in regulation to force overtime.
Colgate 8, No. 13 Army 6: Nate Jones had a natural hat trick, but the Black Knights (5-3, 2-2 Patriot) fell to the Raiders (6-3, 2-2). Colgate went ona 6-0 run in the second half to pull away.
No. 16 Vermont 10, Binghamton 6: Rob Hudson had four goals to lead the host Catamounts (8-1, 1-1 America East) past the Bearcats (1-8, 0-2). Vermont finished on a 4-1 run.
Cornell finished on a 9-2 run to win, after losing their last two games.
Notre Dame 11, No. 9 Syracuse 10, OT: Andie Aldave (McDonogh) scored her second goal and the game-winner with 3:58 left in overtime and the host Fighting Irish (6-5, 2-3 ACC) upset the Orange (6-3, 0-2). Syracuse's Nicole Levy scored the game-tying goal with 2:23 left in regulation to force overtime.
No. 1 Stony Brook 20, UMass-Lowell 7: Courtney Murphy had six goals to lead the visiting Seawolves (8-0, 1-0 America East) past the River Hawks (2-6, 0-1).
No. 6 Florida 16, Georgetown 11: Grace Haus (Notre Dame Prep) had four goals in a come-from-behind victory by the visiting Gators (7-3, 2-0 Big East). The Hoyas (5-3, 1-1) led 8-5 at the half.
No. 7 Penn 16, Brown 10: Erin Barry had five goals and Gabby Rosenzweig had four goals to lead the host Quakers (8-1, 2-0 Ivy) past the Bears (5-4, 0-3).
No. 10 Virginia 12, No. 19 Duke 8: The visiting Cavaliers (7-2, 3-1 ACC) went on a 5-0 run and held the Blue Devils (6-4, 1-2) scoreless for 16 minutes. Avery Shoemaker had four goals for Virginia.
No. 16 Virginia Tech 14, Elon 12: Page Petty had three goals and two assists to lead the visiting Hokies (9-3) past the Phoenix (1-8).
Dartmouth 15, No. 17 Princeton 12: Elizabeth Mastrio had five goals and the visiting Big Green (6-1, 2-0 Ivy) won their sixth straight, beating the Tigers (4-3, 1-1).
No. 18 Stanford 17, Arizona State 7: Ali Baiocco scored a game-high five goals to lead the host Cardinal (6-3, 3-1 Pac-12) past the Sun Devils (5-6, 0-4).