SUBSCRIBE

Baltimore's greatest rivalry? Ravens-Steelers near top of list

Ravens linebacker Terrell Suggs wears a T-shirt that tells the Steel City exactly how he feels about its football team.

Pittsburgh wide receiver Hines Ward spits the words "pure hatred" in reference to Baltimore.

If this week's one-upmanship between the players left any doubt, several of this city's iconic sports figures said that the Ravens- Steelers rivalry — which has its next act Saturday at 4:30 in the AFC divisional playoff — burns with more intensity than any they've known.

Once, the Baltimore Bullets and New York Knicks engaged in games that NBA fans would talk about for decades. The Baltimore Colts warred with the Green Bay Packers in the formative years of the NFL. Not unlike most baseball teams, the Orioles yearned to knock the Yankees from their perch.

But none of those battles reached the fervor that has, with almost unwavering consistency, flared whenever the Ravens and Steelers play.

To one longtime chronicler of Baltimore sports, the game represents this city's reckoning with itself.

"Pittsburgh and Baltimore are made for each other. It's like looking at your own face in the mirror," Frank Deford said. "Both teams play smash-mouth football. Both play in old manufacturing towns with shot-and-a-beer, working-class fans. Both are Rodney Dangerfield cities that get no respect. Pittsburgh is the 'other' city in Pennsylvania, and Baltimore is the other city down Interstate 95."

The similarities intensify the rivalry, said Deford, a Baltimore native who works as a writer and commentator for National Public Radio, HBO and Sports Illustrated.

"You always want to beat someone more who's like you, than someone who's different," Deford said. "That's why Pepsi wants to beat Coke more than it does Schweppes Ginger Ale."

Even members of past Baltimore teams, which also had heated feuds with hated opponents, agree that Ravens-Steelers surpasses, in fervor, any match-up of earlier times.

"I don't remember a rivalry like this one," said Jim Mutscheller, who played for the Colts from 1954-61. "We had tough games against mean and dirty players, but today, even the fans of the Ravens and Steelers are rivals. You didn't see that in our time."

Even the legendary basketball showdowns 40 years ago between the Baltimore Bullets and New York Knicks pale compared to the hoopla surrounding Saturday's contest, said Wes Unseld, the Bullets' Hall of Fame center. For five straight years (1969-73), the Bullets and Knicks met in the playoffs in some of the most storied games in NBA history.

"They (Knicks) were fierce, bitter rivals, but there's no way to compare that to this," Unseld said. "There is mass hysteria going on in this city. Everyone's wearing purple. The Ravens have captured the whole town, and I don't know that we (Bullets) ever did that."

Not everyone agrees. In the 1960s, the Colts' rumbles with the Green Bay Packers were every bit as mythic as those between the Ravens and Steelers, said Bill Curry, the former Colts' center.

"I'm biased, but those were such great teams," said Curry, who played for both Green Bay and Baltimore. "In our era, they were every bit as dominant as these two teams today."

The NFL's elite clubs of the decade, Baltimore and Green Bay — led by coach Vince Lombardi — combined to win three Super Bowls in one five-year span.

"Those teams vied for power, back and forth and back and forth," said Mike Gibbons, executive director of the Sports Legends Museum. "The rivalry with Green Bay was unparalleled and at the top of the list, much as Steelers-Ravens is today."

Of the 11 games in which they met between 1964 and 1970, seven were decided by four points or less — including the Packers' 13-10 overtime victory in a 1965 playoff that was historic on two counts. Injuries forced the Colts to play a halfback, Tom Matte, at quarterback, with the offensive plays written onto a wristband that now rests in the Hall of Fame. Moreover, the game was decided by a disputed field goal, prompting the NFL to raise the height of its goal posts. But old Colts and their fans still grouse about that kick.

"It stuck in our craws, that's for sure," defensive back Bobby Boyd said. "But those games with Green Bay were all-out battles long before that."

The Colts had John Unitas; the Packers, Bart Starr. Both quarterbacks became Hall of Famers and pushed each other to the hilt.

Last year, while visiting the Sports Legends Museum, Starr was shown Unitas' first contract with the Colts, for $7,000 in 1956.

"Bart, who'd made $6,500, just shook his head and said, 'Darn it, he beat me again,' " said Gibbons.

More combative, said Matte, was the Colts' rivalry with the Chicago Bears, their sanguine Western Division opponent from 1953-66.

"We played tense games with Green Bay, but they weren't violent," said Matte, who played with the Colts from 1961-72. "Chicago? Those games were bloodbaths. There was no love lost, and 'Papa Bear' (Chicago coach George Halas) had his team take cheap shots. The Bears told us that if they knocked a Colt player out of the game, they'd get an extra $500 in their paychecks."

The Colts were so sure the Bears were spying on their practices that they posted lookouts, armed with binoculars, in the trees surrounding Memorial Stadium. In 1960, the two-time defending NFL champs were rolling at 6-2 when they met Chicago in November. The Colts won, 24-20, but were so beat up that they dropped their last four contests.

"John (Unitas) left that game with a broken nose and two black eyes," said Gino Marchetti, the Colts' Hall of Fame defensive end. "It was the roughest game I ever played in."

The Orioles' prime adversary wears pinstripes. No team has ruffled their feathers more than the Yankees since the Birds joined the American League in 1954.

"The Orioles didn't draw well for any team in the 1950s, but the Yankees might put 23,000 in the stands," said Gibbons, the museum director. "Whenever the Yankees changed pitchers, the fans waved white hankies. We hated that team."

More so, after the 1958 All-Star Game in Memorial Stadium, in which AL manager Casey Stengal (Yankees) yanked Orioles' catcher Gus Triandos in the 6th inning and replaced him with one of his own, Yogi Berra. Fans booed Stengal mercilessly for the rest of the game. Two years later, the Yankees knocked Baltimore out of first place, for keeps, in September.

"Any time you played New York, you were fired up," said Boog Powell, the Orioles' slugger from 1961-74. "In my day, when New York came to town, you could feel the electricity, the vibes. You saw more signs, more placards, more animation. This was Babe Ruth's team, and it had won 19 million pennants. They were the big, bad boys and we were the little upstarts who had no business being on the same field with them."

And who can forget the 1996 ALCS, when Jeffrey Maier, a 12-year-old Yankees fan, interfered with a fly ball, cost Baltimore a run and, possibly, the pennant?

Even the 19th-century Orioles, a National League power that cowed most teams with its aggressive play, had an archrival. The Cleveland Spiders were the only club whose bullying tactics surpassed those of the Orioles. The Spiders were known to smash locker rooms with their bats, rip the mask off an umpire's face, and grab base runners and toss them about, when the arbiter's back was turned.

Such shenanigans rattled the Orioles, who lost the 1895 Temple Cup (precursor of the World Series) to Cleveland. "A Screw Loose Somewhere Whenever the Baltimores Meet Them," The Sun wrote prior to the 1896 championship series. Then, things changed. The Orioles swept the Spiders in three games. The losers drowned their sorrows in booze and proceeded to beat up a sportswriter in a Cleveland bar.

Compelling rivalries, all, Deford said. But none are as deep-seated as that between Baltimore and Pittsburgh.

"Both teams play brutal football. There's no pretty-boy stuff here, no Tom Brady, who's married to a model, or Peyton Manning, who plays a gentleman's game indoors, on the carpet," Deford said. "Look at the commonality of the two quarterbacks. One (the Ravens' Joe Flacco) went to Delaware; the other (Pittsburgh's Ben Roethlisberger) played at Miami of Ohio.

"And where did John Unitas come from? Pittsburgh. When the Steelers gave him up, they lost a whole generation of victories."

mike.klingaman@baltsun.com

Copyright © 2021, The Baltimore Sun, a Baltimore Sun Media Group publication | Place an Ad

You've reached your monthly free article limit.

Get Unlimited Digital Access

4 weeks for only 99¢
Subscribe Now

Cancel Anytime

Already have digital access? Log in

Log out

Print subscriber? Activate digital access