In Belichick's five seasons as a first-time head coach (1991-95), he went 36-44, with one winning season. He also won a playoff game in 1994, the Browns' last postseason victory. All eight of Cleveland's hired-and-fired coaches since also have finished under .500; Hue Jackson went 1-15 in 2016.
After the 1995 Browns nosedived late in the season and then-owner Art Modell went back on his promise to make Belichick the first coach of his Baltimore franchise, Belichick latched on with the New England Patriots and then the New York Jets as an assistant coach.
“He said if I did it, I’d be making the biggest mistake of my life,” Kraft told Sports Illustrated's Peter King, Kraft's voice "taking an ominous tone," according to King.
The owner, of course, was Modell, and, to be fair, he was not the only person warning Kraft. George Young (Calvert Hall), the former general manager of the New York Giants, and fellow NFL executive Joe Browne "thought I was crazy for wanting Bill," Kraft recalled. "It was toxic. Nobody thought it was a good idea. I was getting killed by the media in Boston. Bill had one winning year in five seasons in Cleveland."
Modell, who died in 2012, reportedly had another conversation with Kraft, one more flattering to his evaluation of a future Hall of Fame coach. According to The Boston Globe, Modell called Kraft up after Belichick was hired in 2000 with a more tempered warning.
"You're not getting Prince Charming," Modell said, "but give him some leeway and he'll deliver for you."
In developments consistent with modern NFL history, everyone but Cleveland benefited. The Ravens won a Super Bowl with Brian Billick, the Patriots won four (and counting) with Belichick, and the Browns continued to be the Browns.