Readers Respond

Let the Roberts' high court be guided by the law, not politics, no matter its members | READER COMMENTARY

Judge Amy Coney Barrett, President Donald Trump's nominee for Supreme Court, during a meeting with Sen. Steve Daines (R-Mont.) at the Capitol in Washington, Thursday, Oct. 1, 2020.

As a practicing lawyer, I have faith in the ability of judges to impartially decide cases before them. Chief Justice John Roberts has made it clear in public comments and in prior rulings that he intends the legacy of the “Roberts Court” to be apolitical, non-partisan and constitutionally independent. I was disappointed that President Donald Trump was given the opportunity for a third nominee during his first, and hopefully only, term as president. But I take solace knowing that, given her age of 48, I expect that Judge Amy Coney Barrett, along with the “younger” justices in the majority, do not want their lengthy judicial legacy to be remembered as a shill for political operatives (“Maryland Sens. Van Hollen, Cardin oppose Barrett’s Supreme Court appointment and say fight isn’t over,” Sept. 26).

These are nine highly intelligent, complex and thoughtful human beings that need to generate personal rapport with each other, build consensus and make lasting and far-reaching rulings for our country. I am confident that, regardless of which side of the aisle a nominee hails, given the average age of the court, they will take that enormous responsibility seriously and will be guided by Constitutional law, not which way the political winds are blowing. Chief Justice Roberts will see to it (I hope).


Alex M. Allman, Forest Hill

Add your voice: Respond to this piece or other Sun content by submitting your own letter.