What will post-pandemic GOP politics look like? | COMMENTARY
By Jonah Goldberg
For The Baltimore Sun|
Apr 10, 2020 at 10:00 AM
I've been telecommuting for decades, so for me sheltering in place isn't remotely the burden it is for a lot of Americans. But it does make the job of following politics more difficult for two reasons.
First, to a certain degree, politics are on lockdown too. To the extent that the Democratic primaries are in the news, it’s mostly as a public health story, thanks to Wisconsin’s debate over whether to carry on with in-person voting and questions of how to conduct a convention while social distancing. Bernie Sanders has dropped out of the race. Joe Biden himself is running a pandemic version of a front porch campaign via teleconference from his home office.
The second reason is more vexing: Nobody has any clue what post-pandemic politics will look like.
On the left, some fantasize about somehow replacing Mr. Biden with New York Gov. Andrew Cuomo, which makes a lot of sense given Mr. Cuomo’s impressive performance of late, except for the near impossibility of orchestrating such a handoff. Meanwhile, progressive groups, still licking their wounds over the almost instantaneous marginalization of Mr. Sanders, are suddenly seeing their massive grassroots organizations starved of money and the ability to organize.
The situation on the right is even more opaque. For good or ill, the pandemic has made President Trump an even more central figure in our politics, thanks to the role the White House plays in a national emergency and his nightly, often rambling, news conferences.
That’s not all to the GOP’s advantage. Mr. Trump’s refusal to admit any error in how he’s handled the crisis has had the unintended effect of starving Republicans of some useful talking points. Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell tried to float the idea that the Democrats’ impeachment fixation distracted Mr. Trump from following through after the travel ban with a more robust response to the pandemic when it would have made a difference, but Mr. Trump himself threw cold water on that.
Regardless, as the right gears up for either a Trump win or a lame duck presidency amid a hard period of recovery, it's possible to glean some contours of post-pandemic Republican politics.
Mr. Trump was always going to be the nominee, but his set of issues has been reshuffled entirely. He was all set to run on a roaring economy, pitting himself against “socialism” — even though his preferred foil, Bernie Sanders, was sidelined on Super Tuesday and is not even in the race anymore. Now, the economy has headed south, and our anti-socialist president is ordering businesses to do the government’s bidding and handing out direct payments to millions of Americans.
Mr. Trump’s vacillation between the need to clamp down on the virus and his desire to open up the economy is somewhat symbolic of the broader divides on the right. Longtime MAGA consigliere Steve Bannon tells The New York Times that the GOP’s commitment to “limited government” is gone forever. Others in the Trumpist orbit, such as Donald Trump Jr., are still pushing the idea that the corona-hype is overblown and just part of an effort to take down his dad.
Somewhere in the middle, conservative politicians and intellectuals are trying to find a less Trumpcentric path.
Long before the coronavirus emerged in Wuhan, China, Sen. Marco Rubio and a coterie of eggheads were firing salvos at “unfettered capitalism” — as if that described the status quo at any point in the last century of American politics — and offering a blueprint for “common good capitalism.” Meanwhile, Nikki Haley, Mr. Trump’s former U.N. ambassador (for whom my wife worked), resigned from the board of Boeing last month in protest over its request for a federal bailout. It was a principled stand, but it’s anyone’s guess whether corporate bailouts will be as unpopular on the right as they were before the pandemic.
While it's hard to know whether crony capitalism will remain out of favor, you can count on China to stay in the doghouse for years to come.
That’s good news for one politician worth watching: Sen. Tom Cotton of Arkansas. Long a China hawk, Mr. Cotton is credited with convincing Mr. Trump to implement the China travel ban (though Mr. Trump didn’t go as far as Cotton wanted). He deserves credit for spotting the threat and speaking out early on. Widely assumed to have presidential aspirations, Mr. Cotton has also deftly managed to avoid being seen as a Trump yes-man — unlike, say, Sen. Lindsey Graham — while remaining a favorite of the president’s.
If the GOP ultimately sours on Mr. Trump’s handling of the crisis, Mr. Cotton would be ideally situated to highlight his prescience. But that’s a long way off, and for now it’s worth noting that Mr. Cotton is running ads supporting the president’s response to the pandemic.