Hillary Clinton's enabler-in-chief

It's an ancient story: An innocent idealist sets out to change the world and in the process becomes what he hates most. "He who fights monsters should see to it that he himself does not become a monster," Friedrich Nietzsche advised.

That's probably the best spin one can put on Sidney Blumenthal, the longtime Hillary Rodham Clinton aide and confidant. But it would be just that -- spin -- given that Mr. Blumenthal was never an idealist, never mind an innocent. He has remained the same man he was in 1976, when he co-edited "Government by Gunplay: Assassination Conspiracy Theories from Dallas to Today." Other contributors to the paranoid collection included renowned JFK assassination conspiracy theorist Carl Oglesby and former CIA officer Philip Agee, who was giving information to the KGB and Cuban intelligence at the time.


The journalist turned Clinton White House courtier is in the news because he shows up in Ms. Clinton's emails -- a lot. (Roughly a third of the last email dump contains email between them.) When first asked about her correspondence with Mr. Blumenthal, Ms. Clinton insisted he was merely "an old friend" who occasionally sent "unsolicited" email.

That was a lie. It turns out that then-Secretary of State Clinton was in near-constant contact with Mr. Blumenthal, urging the head of her "secret spy network" (ProPublica's term) to supply her with information and political advice, mostly about Libya. "Thanks for keeping this stuff coming!" was how she put it in one typical reply.


Nor was he simply acting as an "old friend" either. He was on the payroll of the Clinton Foundation to the tune of $10,000 a month. Media Matters, a self-described media watchdog that serves as Ms. Clinton's shadow communications operation, paid him $200,000 a year.

Rep. Trey Gowdy (R-S.C.), the chairman of the House Select Committee on Benghazi, alleges Mr. Blumenthal had significant business interests in toppling the Libyan regime because he was working with a firm seeking contracts with what he hoped would be the new Libyan government. Mr. Gowdy claims that Mr. Blumenthal disclosed the name of an undercover operative in an email Ms. Clinton forwarded over her unsecured server.

Ms. Clinton had no choice but to run Mr. Blumenthal off the books because the Obama administration banned him. Then-White House Chief of Staff Rahm Emanuel -- who in the 1990s nicknamed Mr. Blumenthal "G.K." for "grassy knoll" -- knew to keep the conspiracy-minded aide at arm's length. It probably never occurred to him that Ms. Clinton would go to such lengths to keep her factotum on the team.

But what does it say about Ms. Clinton that she just can't do without her pet? Part of the answer is that Mr. Blumenthal is a legendary sycophant. But the means of his sycophancy are more relevant. He serves as Ms. Clinton's enabler: a rumor-mongering Wormtongue whispering confirmation of the vast right-wing conspiracy that the Nixonian Ms. Clinton sees everywhere. Even as a journalist, Mr. Blumenthal played this role. He urged the Clinton administration to craft a dossier on the conspiracy driving negative coverage of the Clintons, including in such right-wing rags as the Washington Post.

When Mr. Blumenthal finally landed a job in the Clinton White House, the most frequently told joke in Washington was about how he could finally collect his back pay. One of his chief tasks in the White House was to lie to reporters about the Monica Lewinsky scandal and the independent counsel's investigation. He infamously claimed that a grand jury had interrogated him about private conversations with journalists. He made it up.

In a chapter in "Government by Gunplay" (defending the Black Panthers), Mr. Blumenthal writes of J. Edgar Hoover: "He had a Manichean vision, convinced that all evil emanated from a single source and that all of the devil's work was of a single pattern." Elsewhere in the book, he writes, "The guardians of the established order see themselves as the only fit rulers."

This is precisely how Mr. Blumenthal sees the world: a contest between enlightened rulers and evil ones, where power requires making up your own rules. "If you hate a person, you hate something in him that is part of yourself," observed Hermann Hesse. "What isn't part of ourselves doesn't disturb us."

And that's what makes him Hillary Clinton's indispensable man.


Jonah Goldberg is a fellow at the American Enterprise Institute and a senior editor of National Review. You can write to him in care of this newspaper or by e-mail at, or via Twitter @JonahNRO.