Lobbying intensifies among VP candidates as Joe Biden’s search nears an end
By Jonathan Martin, Alexander Burns and Katie Glueck
The New York Times|
Jul 31, 2020 at 2:39 PM
WASHINGTON — Joe Biden has entered the final stage of his deliberations about choosing a running mate as he prepares to talk one-on-one with the finalists next week, while Democratic leaders lobby him furiously to elevate their allies and sink their enemies.
Biden’s campaign has conducted extensive polling and focus groups with voters on a collection of candidates and weighed an array of factors, such as the impact of the pick in battleground states and whether to choose a Black woman. Aides said the announcement will come the week before the Democratic convention in August.
Two candidates who received scant attention early in the process are now among the most formidable contenders: Rep. Karen Bass of California and Susan Rice, the former national security adviser, according to Democratic officials briefed on the selection process. Bass in particular has moved rapidly toward the top of Biden’s list amid an intensive lobbying drive by her fellow House Democrats, including prominent members of the Congressional Black Caucus.
Biden is said to be focused on finding a running mate he regards as capable of advancing his priorities in governing and who can be counted on not to stray from the urgent challenges facing the nation to pursue their own political priorities, according to people familiar with his thinking. His advisers would also prefer a running mate who would not present a rich political target for President Donald Trump, given that the incumbent is lagging badly in the polls and has so far struggled to deliver credible negative attacks against Biden.
James Clyburn, the third-ranking House Democrat who helped revive Biden’s campaign in South Carolina, said he had been bombarded by supporters of several candidates.
“I’ve heard from the surrogates of about all the people in the race,” said Clyburn, who did not rule out making a late, private recommendation to Biden.
In conversations with Biden and his vetting committee, lawmakers have recommended Bass as a consensus candidate who is well-liked across partisan and factional lines and would be a loyal lieutenant to him in government.
Bass has reinforced that message by assuring Democratic officials that she has no interest in seeking the presidency herself, according to lawmakers directly familiar with the discussions. That commitment could assuage concerns in the Biden camp that he might be overshadowed by a running mate positioning herself to succeed him.
Bass has also waged a previously undisclosed campaign to woo influential liberal leaders, telephoning union presidents to seek their counsel and support.
“I had a great conversation with Karen Bass,” said Randi Weingarten, head of the American Federation of Teachers, adding that Bass had made her interest in the vice presidency clear. “She talked to me about how real it was.”
House Speaker Nancy Pelosi is close with Bass, whom she named to oversee the recent policing reform bill, and has made her admiration clear in private conversations, including with former President Barack Obama. Pelosi’s aides said she has not conveyed support for any one candidate, is fond of a number of them and, in speaking with Biden’s vetting team last month, urged them to find somebody who could ensure the ticket is victorious.
Two prominent Democrats, Sens. Elizabeth Warren of Massachusetts and Kamala Harris of California, along with a handful of other women, remain as possibilities; both lawmakers have the statewide political experience and large national followings that Bass and Rice lack. Warren has become something of an informal adviser to Biden on economic issues and has won support from her party’s progressive wing, and Harris is regarded as a muscular fundraiser with the backing of important people in the Democratic Party’s donor class.
While Biden’s advisers are careful to stress that he has not ruled out any of the major candidates, some are clearly less likely than others to be chosen. For some of the long-shot candidates, talk has already turned to other potential roles in a Biden administration: Gov. Michelle Lujan Grisham of New Mexico, for instance, has expressed interest in the job of health and human services secretary, according to officials familiar with her thinking.
Among the other candidates Biden has looked at closely are Gov. Gretchen Whitmer of Michigan; Rep. Val Demings of Florida, who has enlisted her home state’s sizable congressional delegation to make appeals on her behalf; and Sen. Tammy Duckworth of Illinois, who is backed by veterans advocates.
Gov. J.B. Pritzker of Illinois has called Biden’s team to urge them to put Duckworth, a military veteran, on the ticket; and Sen. Jack Reed of Rhode Island, the top Democrat on the Senate Armed Services Committee, has shared his high opinion of the combat-wounded Duckworth with the Biden camp, people familiar with the conversations said.
Some contenders have been trying to position themselves in the same fashion as Bass. Harris and Rice have asked senior Democratic officials to make their case to Biden and the vetting committee. Harris has also reached out to some labor leaders, and Demings has contacted some of Biden’s longtime allies.
The former vice president’s decision has become both enormously consequential and highly delicate because of the unresolved question of whether, should he win in November, he would seek reelection in four years, when he would be nearly 82 years old. With his selection, Biden may be effectively coronating the next Democratic presidential nominee and charting the party’s course for the next decade.
This is why some progressives are hoping he balances the ticket by picking a more liberal running mate.
“It shouldn’t be someone that just amplifies what Biden does well,” said Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez of New York. “It should be somebody that brings new constituencies to the table.”
Some of his top advisers, however, are warning against tapping somebody who would begin eyeing the next Democratic primary as a Biden administration races to secure a vaccine for the coronavirus and revive the economy.
“There’s going to be an awful lot to do starting on day one, so I think it’s important to have somebody who can be focused on that task and not running for president as soon as we finish the inauguration,” said Rep. Cedric Richmond of Louisiana, one of Biden’s campaign chairs.
Biden’s top aides have made clear the premium he places on a trusting relationship is informed by his own experience as a vice president — and he will not make a nakedly political choice, a determination made easier by the sizable advantage he enjoys over Trump in the polls.
“The Bidens are looking for somebody as loyal to them as they were to Barack and Michelle Obama,” said Christine Pelosi, the daughter of the speaker.
Biden’s campaign is angry about a leak to Politico this week that revealed that former Sen. Christopher Dodd, one of the leaders of Biden’s search team, is uneasy with Harris, believing it will make Biden’s selection more awkward. Dodd has repeatedly indicated to allies that he believed Biden should broaden the prospects and not focus on only well-known possibilities.
Dodd is scarcely alone in his lack of enthusiasm for Harris, whose own presidential campaign never matched its high expectations; she dropped out two months before voting began.
“The thing I keep thinking about Kamala is her performance in the primary,” said Rep. Filemon Vela of Texas, an early supporter of Biden. Vela said his top three choices were Bass, Rice and Duckworth — but he said the last two would fare best in his state.
Former Gov. Tom Vilsack of Iowa echoed that view of Duckworth and said Demings, too, would have wide appeal because of her former career as a police chief.
One Democrat close to Biden’s campaign said its polling indicated that Harris has little allure with Black voters. More telling, a Biden campaign official reached out to The New York Times, unprompted, to say that some of the former vice president’s own staff members are not supportive of her.
California Democrats, including several in Congress, have expressed their wariness about Harris to Biden’s advisers. In some cases, they have guided him in the direction of Bass, who is highly regarded in her home state.
David Crane, a Democrat and former top adviser to Arnold Schwarzenegger when he was governor of California, said he had reached out to Biden’s camp to tell them Bass was “a good person who cares about legislation.” He said he conveyed his belief that she would be a far better partner for Biden than Harris, who he said did not “walk her talk” on policy.
“They’ve got to pick somebody who really knows how to govern,” Crane said, stressing what he described as Bass’ gift for steering complex legislation. “Karen Bass knows how to do that. Kamala Harris has never been in that position.”
Harris does have allies.
“I think the world of her,” said former Sen. Harry Reid of Nevada, who spoke with Harris on Thursday.
“You only need to look at her record at the local, state and federal levels to know that she’d be a quality, experienced partner who’s ready to lead on day one,” added Rusty Hicks, who also praised Bass and is neutral in his capacity as chair of the California Democratic Party.
While Rice has a close relationship with Biden, many in the party are wary of elevating somebody who has never run for office.
Bass, too, has drawbacks. She has never been in a setting comparable to a high-stakes debate with Vice President Mike Pence. And in private vetting conversations, members of Biden’s team have also asked Bass to explain aspects of her record on Cuba: She took a trip to the country as a teenager and issued a respectful statement of condolence when Fidel Castro died in 2016. Bass has said publicly that she had reconsidered those comments and would not make them again.
Clearly, though, Biden is facing the most intense lobbying to choose a Black running mate.
Breaking News Alerts Newsletter
As it happens
Get updates on the coronavirus pandemic and other news as it happens with our free breaking news email alerts.
A small group of strategists and activists who have been pressing for a Black woman recently spoke with members of the search committee, according to two people with knowledge of the conversation. They discussed the electoral map and how the political environment in the country had shifted following the killing of George Floyd in police custody in May.
When given the opportunity to make a case for a specific candidate, participants indicated their support of any of the Black women considered, but Harris and Rice came up the most, the people familiar with the conversation said. They noted that the meeting unfolded before it was evident how seriously Bass was being considered.
In the House, there’s a groundswell for Bass. Several Democratic lawmakers have made the case for her to Biden’s advisers.
Rep. Josh Gottheimer of New Jersey, a centrist leader of the bipartisan Problem Solvers Caucus, called Bass “a bridge-builder” who “wants to figure out how to get to yes.”
Rep. Ro Khanna of California, an outspoken progressive, was equally succinct: “She’d be a pick that every part of the Democratic coalition would respect and be excited about.”