Wheelabrator Baltimore, the company that disposes of the bulk of the region’s trash, recently sent out direct mail asking residents to call on the City Council to reject a proposed Clean Air Ordinance. Here's what the bill would do — and what the flyer left out.
What the bill would do
It would require large incinerators in the city to reduce their emissions of nitrogen oxides to a concentration of 45 parts per million, on par with standards imposed on newly constructed incinerators. That is a far more stringent standard than a Maryland Department of the Environment nitrogen oxide limit of 145 parts per million averaged over 30 days.
It would also impose limits to sulfur dioxide and mercury emissions that are on par with the emissions controls on new incinerators. And it would require constant monitoring for a variety of pollutants, shared online in real time.
It would apply to Wheelabrator Baltimore, a trash incinerator whose white smokestack towers over Interstate 95 near Russell Street, and Curtis Bay Energy, the largest medical waste incinerator in the country. Wheelabrator burns household trash from across the city and also from around the region and state.
Wheelabrator’s flyer, and a new website GetTheFactsBmore.com, stress that the Environmental Protection Agency prefers waste incineration to landfills and that it meets hundreds of air quality and other environmental standards every day. That is all true — the EPA endorsed the technology even under President Barack Obama, saying it produces less greenhouse gases than landfills do.
The company also stresses that the city has no plan for disposal of its non-recyclable waste without the Wheelabrator incinerator. That is true, for now, and it’s relevant because the company says it would have to close the incinerator if the Clean Air Ordinance is passed. At a hearing last week, Jim Connolly, vice president of environmental, health and safety for Wheelabrator Technologies, said only a brand-new facility could comply with the pollution standards the ordinance would impose.
But there are facts the flyer leaves out: The Wheelabrator incinerator is Baltimore’s chief industrial source of pollution including lead, mercury, hydrochloric acid and formaldehyde. City Council members and residents say they fear the facility is contributing to unusually high levels of asthma and other respiratory diseases in Baltimore.
On its website, Clean Air Baltimore has fact-checked Wheelabrator’s flyer, including suggesting that the EPA’s endorsement of incinerators is flawed. The group suggests that by increasing recycling rates, the city can lessen any impact if the incinerator were to close. And, it says, the city should be moving away from waste incineration, anyway.
The City Council is scheduled to take a preliminary vote on the bill Monday night. If it passes, it could come up for a final vote as soon as Feb. 11.
City Council members are also scheduled to meet with city finance officials behind closed doors Friday to discuss the potential costs of the legislation.