City faulted for deliberately dumping sewage into Jones Falls

Doris and Charles Brightful stand in front of the northwest Baltimore home they've lived in for over 50 years. In September, a city sewer flooded their basement. It was the second time that sewage has flowed into their basement because of sewer overcapacity in their area.
Doris and Charles Brightful stand in front of the northwest Baltimore home they've lived in for over 50 years. In September, a city sewer flooded their basement. It was the second time that sewage has flowed into their basement because of sewer overcapacity in their area. (Barbara Haddock Taylor / Baltimore Sun)

A new report details how Baltimore has deliberately dumped more than 330 million gallons of raw sewage over the past five years into the Jones Falls, which flows into the Inner Harbor.

Elsewhere in the city's 1,400-mile network of aged underground pipes, the report by the Environmental Integrity Project notes, there have been more than 400 complaints of sewage backing up into homes.


The intentional overflows — releasing 15 times as much sewage as the city has reported spilling from pipe breaks and blockages — are coming from two openings in the sewer system that the city was supposed to close years ago, according to the Washington-based environmental group. The releases are intended to avoid sewage backups into homes from the city's leaky, overloaded sewer system.

The report, based on public information requests, comes as the city is nearing a deadline it will not meet for fixing the system.


City officials say they have spent $700 million on sewer repairs to comply with a consent order signed in 2002 with the Environmental Protection Agency and the Maryland Department of the Environment. The order, settling a lawsuit brought against the city for polluting local waters, requires an end to chronic overflows by Jan. 1.

But with just two weeks to go before the deadline, the city has completed only about half the repairs and upgrades it pledged to make, according to the report.

Jeff Raymond, a spokesman for the city's Department of Public Works, said municipal officials hope to get an extension from state and federal regulators, but said he could not discuss how much longer the overhaul would take until a new timetable is filed with the federal court. Officials have said previously that they expect to spend more than $1 billion to complete it.

The environmental group and local activists are calling on state and federal regulators to grant the city no more than five more years to finish its sewer work, in keeping with a campaign the city has embraced to make the harbor swimmable and fishable by 2020.

"They need to get it done," said Eric Schaeffer, a former EPA official who directs the Environmental Integrity Project. "It's been 13 years now," he said, recalling that he worked on the city's consent decree before leaving the federal agency. "They need to pick up the pace."

Activists also insist that people be alerted to the health risks of kayaking, sailing or otherwise coming into contact with Inner Harbor waters that are frequently contaminated with sewage.

"We're seeing a lot more people out on the water boating and fishing," said David Flores, the Baltimore Harbor Waterkeeper, who says the city ought to be more open about how much sewage is being spilled into the harbor and the streams that feed it.

Decades ago, the city designed its sewer system to overflow into the nearest stream whenever sewage backed up in the lines. Since signing the consent decree, the city has closed 60 of 62 relief valves. But officials say that if they close the last two overflow outfalls on the Jones Falls, it could cause sewage to back up into homes and businesses in much of the city.

"Our regulators are aware that these are open," Raymond said. City officials plan to plug the overflows "down the line," he added.

Many of the overflows occur because of a problem with the pipe feeding into the century-old Back River wastewater treatment plant, officials say. The city planned to issue a contract last summer to remedy the backups by pumping sewage into huge holding tanks but officials rejected the low bid because it was more than $100 million over the $300 million that municipal engineers had estimated.

City officials are reviewing the project to figure out how to lower the cost, Raymond said. Construction is now projected to begin in 2017 and take three years.

Activists contend that the city is not being open enough about how much sewage is being spilled or the risks the public faces. Water samples taken regularly by the city since 2009 show potentially unsafe levels of fecal bacteria occur frequently in the Inner Harbor and the lower Jones Falls.


The city is required by state regulations to alert the public when there is a sewage spill or overflow of more than 10,000 gallons. But the much larger releases from the two built-in overflow valves on the Jones Falls are not reported promptly and only rarely get announced to news media or the public, the report noted.

Edward J. Bouwer, a professor and chairman of the department of geography and environmental engineering at the Johns Hopkins University, said he believes the city ought to be posting warning signs around the Inner Harbor. "I suspect that people out there have no idea," he said.

"I wouldn't say, 'Kayakers, don't kayak.' Just be aware that the water has high fecal levels. If it gets in the mouth, that could cause someone to get sick."

Raymond said city officials do not believe they are required to publicize sewage releases from the unclosed outfalls. They are reported to regulators on a quarterly basis, he said. And he noted that there are three permanent signs along the lower Jones Falls advising the public that the stream could be contaminated, though he acknowledged that there are no similar postings around the harbor.

David Sternberg, a spokesman for the EPA's Mid-Atlantic regional office, said federal regulators still are talking with state and city officials about amending the consent decree.

The EPA and the state are reviewing the city's request to leave the two overflow valves open for the time being, Sternberg said, but they are also looking into complaints that the city has not properly notified the public of all spills.

Jay Apperson, a spokesman for the Maryland Department of the Environment, acknowledged that the closing of the two overflow outfalls has been delayed until other repairs can be made. He said regulators had given the city a draft revision, but that it remains under negotiation.

"Everyone knows that this can be a challenging and expensive problem to solve," Apperson said. "We are working on an amended consent decree that takes into account the logistical challenges while insisting on continued environmental progress."

Halle Van der Gaag, executive director of the environmental group Blue Water Baltimore, said she wants regulators and the city to address the residential sewage backups detailed in the report. Any plan to correct the overflows also should offer relief to residents whose homes have been fouled through no fault of their own, she said.

"This isn't just about kayakers on the Inner Harbor," she said. "It's about people being impacted in their homes. It's disgusting."

Sewage backups have been reported all over the city, according to the report, with a flurry in a few Northwest Baltimore neighborhoods.


Charles and Doris Brightful, longtime residents of Grove Park, say their basement has flooded with raw sewage twice in the past two years during heavy rains. In the most recent episode, foul-smelling waste about 8 inches deep filled their basement in late September, and they had to replace the furnace, hot water heater and furniture they had purchased to replace what they had thrown out after the backup the year before.

While insurance paid for much of the cleanup and repairs this fall, Doris Brightful said she and her husband, both 79 and retired, had to pay $7,000 up front. They said their requests for reimbursement for both backups have been denied by the city.

Raymond, the public works spokesman, blamed backups in those neighborhoods on sewer lines that are too small to handle the flow, especially when rainfall leaks in through cracks and breaks in the pipes. He said the city plans to begin work next year to install larger sewer pipes there and to plug the leaks upstream.

The city also is eyeing installing a backflow preventer in the sewer main in the Brightfuls' neighborhood, he said.

"That is still on the drawing board," Raymond said. "We don't have a solid time frame for that."

Meanwhile, Charles Brightful said, "every time they mention rain, I get paranoid."

Recommended on Baltimore Sun