A look at recent Baltimore Police scandals

From the death of Freddie Gray to scandals over surveillance airplanes and body-camera videos, the Baltimore Police Department has had a rocky three years. The disclosure of several internal affairs investigations offers the most recent examples.

Disclosure of several internal affairs cases


At a police oversight briefing with Baltimore City Council on Oct. 10, several internal affairs cases came to light, including:

» That seven officers are under internal investigation connected o the department’s corrupt Gun Trace Task Force


» There is a probe into financial misconduct tied to recruitment in Puerto Rico, where the Police Department has sought to hire Spanish-speaking officers.

» A lieutenant was disciplined after being overheard on a wiretap tied to the gun unit investigation sharing answers to a sergeant’s exam

» 20 officers were facing criminal charges as of last week

Officer fired after being found intoxicated in his patrol vehicle

In October 2018, Officer Aaron Heilman was fired after being found intoxicated and slumped over in his patrol vehicle near Pigtown. A Breathalyzer revealed his blood alcohol level was 0.22. Heilman was charged with DUI-related offenses and suspended. He was later fired by interim Commissioner Garry Tuggle.

Police commander quits after slamming chair

A high-ranking Baltimore Police commander quit after slamming a chair into a wall during a heated meeting with interim Commissioner Garry Tuggle’s chief of staff. A flier obtained by The Baltimore Sun that reads, “BOLO” or “be on the lookout,” says Col. Perry Standfield is “not allowed at City Hall, BPD headquarters or any other BPD property unless properly escorted.” Police spokesman T.J. Smith later said in a statement that the flier had been “disseminated erroneously.”

“There’s no organization in the department,” Standfield told The Baltimore Sun after the incident. “There’s a lot of infighting that the public doesn’t know about, doesn’t see. I can’t be a part of it. I’m not that type of person.”


Officer shown punching a man on video

In August 2018, a viral video emerged showing a Baltimore police officer repeatedly punching a man in the face before taking him to the ground. The officer resigned from the department. He was later charged with first- and second-degree assault and misconduct in office. Warren Brown, an attorney for the man who was beaten, had previously identified the officer as Arthur Williams, who graduated from the Baltimore Police training academy in April and has been with the department since last year.

Officer arrested for drug trafficking charges

Officer Spencer P. Moore, a 14-year veteran of the city police department, was charged in July 2018 with drug violations after Baltimore County officers say they saw him involved in a “narcotics transaction” in a parking lot in Woodlawn. Interim police Commissioner Gary Tuggle said Moore had been on suspension with pay for several months stemming from a prior incident, and that he’s now on unpaid suspension pending the outcome of the criminal case.

Officer declines to respond to report of a man with a gun

In July 2018, an officer was flagged down by a firefighter who’d seen a man with a gun downtown — but the officer declined to respond because it wasn’t in her district. She no longer works for the department.


Police commander, target of investigation, is suspended

A high-ranking Baltimore police commander was suspended from the department after The Baltimore Sun revealed she was being investigated for using funds from a police-community relations nonprofit to pay for plane tickets for a personal European vacation. Maj. Kimberly Burrus was also recalled from an elite national police fellowship with the International Association of Chiefs of Police. Burrus later filed a criminal complaint against her ex-husband, Capt. Torran Burrus, alleging that he burglarized her home to obtain evidence used against her in the theft case; he was also suspended from the department. The Baltimore State’s Attorney’s Office decided not to pursue charges against either Burrus.

Commissioner Darryl De Sousa resigns

In May 2018, Baltimore Police Commissioner Darryl De Sousa resigned over a federal investigation into his personal finances and other private and professional affairs. De Sousa stepped down after federal prosecutors charged him last week with failing to file federal tax returns. They have also sent subpoenas to the city’s finance and police departments for a decade’s worth of information about his pay, travel, secondary jobs, taxes and internal affairs files. Deputy Commissioner Gary Tuggle was named his interim replacement, and Mayor Catherine Pugh announced a national search for the next commissioner.

Commissioner Kevin Davis fired

In January 2018, Mayor Catherine Pugh fired Baltimore Police Commissioner Kevin Davis. Pugh cited the stubbornly high levels of street violence as reason for his firing. Davis was appointed acting commissioner in July 2015, after then-Mayor Stephanie Rawlings-Blake fired former Commissioner Anthony Batts in the wake of protests over the death of Freddie Gray. Davis had previously worked as chief of Anne Arundel County Police.


Det. Sean Suiter’s death

In November 2017, Baltimore Police Det. Sean Suiter was shot and killed in West Baltimore, the day before he was to testify before a federal grand jury in the Gun Trace Task Force case. Police have said Suiter was not a target of the investigation. Police initially said Suiter was shot once in the head at close range in a brief, violent struggle with an unknown suspect, but subsequently acknowledged that investigators are also reviewing other theories — including that Suiter may have committed suicide, an idea Suiter’s family has rejected. The case remains unsolved.

Escalating violence

A bloody 2017 ended with 342 killings in Baltimore. The surge in street violence was a per-capita record for the city, after 318 killings in 2016 and 342 killings in 2015. Prior to that, there hadn’t been 300 homicides in Baltimore in a single year since 1999.

Body camera tampering

In summer 2017, the release of three police body camera videos caused defense attorneys to allege officers were planting drugs on suspects. In the most notable case, Officer Richard A. Pinheiro Jr. was charged in January with misconduct and fabricating evidence. Pinheiro’s video shows the officer placing a soup can into a trash-strewn lot. That portion of the footage was recorded automatically. After placing the can down, the officer walks to the street and flips his camera on. He returns to the lot, picks up the soup can, and removes a plastic bag filled with white capsules. He is scheduled for trial in August. The video drew national attention, and prosecutors said it caused them to drop more than 100 cases.


The public defender's office says this police body camera footage from a January drug arrest shows an officer placing a bag of drugs in a trash strewn lot. The officer can then be seen walking to the street, where he flips on his body camera, returns to the lot and picks up a soup can containing a bag of drugs. 

Police cameras have a feature that saves 30 seconds of video prior to activation, but without audio. When the officer is first in the alley, there is no audio until 30 seconds later.

Consent Decree

In April 2017, a federal judge ordered sweeping police reforms, known as a consent decree, after months of negotiations between the Baltimore Police Department and Justice Department. Federal investigators with the Justice Department found that police in Baltimore routinely violated the constitutional rights of local residents, particularly in predominantly poor, black neighborhoods; used excessive force; mistreated protesters, youths and people with mental disabilities; and dismissed sexual assault complaints improperly, among other failings.

Gun Trace Task Force

In March 2017, federal agents arrested seven Baltimore police officers charged in a racketeering conspiracy. The officers from an elite gun squad, called the Gun Trace Task Force, were accused of robbing drug dealers and cheating on their overtime pay. An eighth officer and former commander of the unit was later charged. Eight members of the Gun Trace Task Force were convicted.

Spy plane

In August 2016, revelations emerged that a private company has been conducting secret aerial surveillance on behalf of the Baltimore Police Department and collecting and storing footage from city neighborhoods. The operation, funded by Houston philanthropists Laura and John Arnold, was not disclosed to the public or, initially, to elected officials, including then-Mayor Stephanie Rawlings-Blake. When the program’s existence was revealed, officials and others slammed the police department. Civil liberties advocates said the plane allowed the government to track residents for hours without warrants and with little oversight. The program was grounded. Police said at the time that if they were to try to resurrect it, they would make the process public.


Freddie Gray

In April 2015, Freddie Gray died of spinal injuries he suffered in the back of a police van. His death was followed by massive protests and riots across Baltimore. In a dramatic news conference, Baltimore State’s Attorney Marilyn Mosby charged the six officers involved in Gray’s arrest and transport. Three of them were acquitted by a judge and Mosby dropped charges against the rest. In September, the U.S. Department of Justice announced it would not bring federal charges against the officers.

Baltimore Sun reporters Jessica Anderson, Justin Fenton and Kevin Rector contributed to this article.