Baltimore State’s Attorney Marilyn Mosby told a state policing commission that she has concerns about the integrity of more than 300 police officers and may not be able to put them on the witness stand, a claim downplayed by the department’s head of internal affairs who said he stands behind the vast majority of those officers.
“We have 305 officers with integrity issues and/or allegations of integrity issues that would in essence put them in jeopardy from testifying,” Mosby told members of the state Commission to Restore Trust in Policing at a day-long meeting at the University of Baltimore Law School.
The panel was formed to identify issues within the department that allowed the corrupt Gun Trace Task Force officers to operate for years until they were caught, convicted and imprisoned by federal prosecutors.
Nadeau said the state’s attorney’s office list can be used by prosecutors to flag what is known as Brady/Giglio material — information about an officer that could benefit the defense and therefore should be disclosed to defense attorneys.
Nadeau said he agreed that 22 officers on the list should not be called to testify, but only two of those officers remain with the department and both are undergoing an administrative review. Nadeau also said he doesn’t know of any cases that have not been brought because of officers on the state’s attorney’s office list.
Outside of those 22, Nadeau said, nothing would preclude the rest of the officers from testifying or doing their jobs.
“Nobody on that list that I wouldn’t have working on the street, making cases," he said.
But Sean Malone, a commission member and attorney, questioned Nadeau about the number of officers on the list, saying "that’s just a disturbing number.”
Nadeau told the commission that he was not as concerned about the figure, saying that “quite a few" of the officers named were subjects of complaints that were not sustained.
When an officer is accused of wrongdoing, he or she is investigated by officers from internal affairs, who typically find a complaint sustained or not sustained. When cases are sustained, internal affairs investigators recommend discipline. Officers can accept the finding and any discipline or elect to go before a trial board, which also can recommend discipline, up to and including dismissal. Police Commissioner Michael Harrison has the final say.
Mosby’s deputy, Michael Schatzow, told the panel that the state’s attorney’s office has a much broader policy for disclosing information to the defense than other agencies, and that material passed on to attorneys isn’t necessarily admissible in court.
Neither Mosby nor Nadeau provided a breakdown of the status of the 305 officers, including how many of them faced allegations that were sustained, or even how many still remain with the department.
Mosby said the list was intended to identify material that should be shared with defense attorneys but also to alert the department of any possible issues with its officers.
Breaking News Alerts Newsletter
As it happens
Get updates on the coronavirus pandemic and other news as it happens with our free breaking news email alerts.
During Nadeau’s presentation, he also spoke about broader reforms the department is implementing to improve how internal affairs cases are handled, including an effort to reduce the time between when a complaint is filed to when an investigation is closed. He said he hopes to see that drop from one year to 90 days.
“The problem is the volume of cases," he said.
Nadeau said the department is seeking to transfer 11 new detectives into internal affairs, and train more officers. He said the department also is reforming its intake process to allow less serious, more straightforward cases in which the officer acknowledges wrongdoing to be processed more quickly.
Nadeau also said the department wants to hire a research analyst next year to evaluate where the majority of internal affairs complaints originate. He hopes to determine if problems are found in a specific district or whether there’s a broader training issue, to help address those issues before they become complaints.