Maj. Melvin Russell, of the Eastern District, along with Maj. Sabrina Tapp-Harper of the Northern District, discuss crime trends at a public Comstat police commanders' meeting

With a series of shootings occuring in the Northern District in close proximity, police leaders asked Maj. Sabrina Tapp-Harper whether she had a handle on the problem.

It was not unlike what she and other district commanders face weekly at police strategy meetings, called Comstat. But for Thursday night's meeting, the public for the first time was also looking on, in-person and over computer screens.


Tapp-Harper expressed confidence that her district was on top of it, noting that a known gang member had been released from prison Wednesday night and officers had already paid him a visit.

For that, she got a round of applause from some of the residents in attendance.

This was obviously unlike any Comstat session these commanders have been to. Comstat has been in Baltimore since the late 1990s, brought here from New York by then-Mayor Martin O'Malley, and involves a weekly huddling to share statistics, analyze strategy and discuss investigations.

Police Commissioner Anthony Batts, in his second month on the job, made the call to give residents a taste of what the meetings are like, at a time when homicides are gun violence are spiking.

Mayor Stephanie Rawlings-Blake, who dropped by the meeting after a budget work session, said taking the meeting on the road was part of a broader effort to increase citizen involvement. "There's more to come," she promised. "I know in my heart that when we work hand-in-hand, we'll make progress that'll blow everyone's minds."

Abdul Muhsiy, 61, who lives in Gwynn Oak but owns a home in the Western district, found Batts responsive after he voiced complaints of disrespectful comments from officers on two occasions. After relaying to Batts the lackadaisical response that he received, the commissioner told Muhsiy that an Internal Affairs investigator would call him tomorrow.

"What he said is very, very essential, and I was pleased with how he responded," Muhsiy said.

Linda Towe, a volunteer with Project T.O.O.U.R., a community building group in Westport, said the meeting consisted of a lot of "stuff we'd heard before."

She said she wasn't impressed when Batts told attendees that the "no-snitch" phenomenon plaguing prosecutions was mostly myth. Experience told him hardened criminals snitch on each other all the time for lenient sentences, he said.

But Towe said she knows teens who've been killed for identifying suspects.

"Kids get shot and killed," she said. "It is an issue. They kind of waltzed over it like it's ok."

To kick off the meeting, the department went right to its districts that have been hit hardest in recent weeks, calling the Northern and Eastern districts. There's been eight shootings along Greenmount Avenue in recent weeks, on the border between the two districts. Alarmingly, two people were shot in the middle of the day just a block from where three people were shot the previous night.

"What broke down there?" asked Col. Dean Palmere, the chief of patrol.

Officers, the commanders said, were in the immediate area for both shootings - in the first, an officer saw the muzzle flash in his rearview mirror. In the second, officers were on the next street over. To police, it underscored the brazen nature of the city's crime.


"[Even] with all the deployment in place, there's still this level of tenaciousness," Deputy Commissioner John Skinner said.

In the triple shooting, 16-year-old Daniel Pearson, who was known on the streets as "Funny," was killed. Tapp-Harper, flanked by a homicide unit supervisor, said detectives have physical evidence and expect the the case to be solved. Meanwhile, she said the two men shot in the double shooting the next day - one of whom is also 16 years old - are paralyzed, and she said there investigators see gang connections in both cases.

Tapp-Harper and Maj. Melvin Russell, who leads the Eastern District, said they've developed intelligence packets on suspected criminals in the area, and are sharing that information and letting officers move between districts.

"Those borders no longer exist," she said. Both said they had community meetings planned to get the public involved.

Cognizant of the public looking on, Tapp-Harper started to describe a sensitive strategy and got the "cut it off" sign from a smiling Batts.

Maj. Johnny Delgado, the commander of the Northwestern District, was also asked how a shooting could have occurred in his district despite the area being well-trafficked. Delgado responded that two officers were working a foot patrol beat just one block away.

"When you talk about putting people where the crime is, that's pretty close," Delgado, saying the deployment has generally helped tamp down crime in that area.

With strong support in the audience from his district, Delgado told police brass - and Rawlings-Blake, who joined the meeting during his time - that he needed more resources. The question came after Batts asked what had changed in the district to cause a spike in homicides.

"What we lost was very basic part of policing: we lost the ominpresence of cops," Delgado said. He explained that last year, he was able to identify eight "hot zones" in his district, and keep officers on them continuously. "This year, I haven't been able to do that," he said. In his district, "if you don't see a cop every three minutes, we'll have a problem."

Delgado said he's bracing for a seasonal spike in robberies in the areas around Reisterstown Plaza and described his plan.

"We have a lot of work to do," Delgado said. "Every day is not a perfect day. But we'll continue on our relentless pursuit to catch these guys and put them in jail."

In his first comments as commissioner last month, Batts said that while continuing to reduce homicides is important, he also wanted to emphasize quality-of-life crimes that affect a broader swath of residents. With homicides picking up this month, much of his attention has been focused on that area and so did Thursday's Comstat.

But he took time at the end to tick off other types of crime that are on the decline, and promised residents that his public affairs office is at work on coming up with new ways to share information and interact with the community.

Phil Leaf, senior associate director of the Urban Health Institute at Johns Hopkins University and a Roland Park resident, was measured in his assessment of the meeting but found it positive overall.
"There seemed to be good rapport with the community that came out," he said.
Batts "seems personable and knows what he's talking about," Leaf added. "He's been here for two months. He seems to be off to a positive start."