NEW YORK - It takes a few seconds before I find my plate. First, my fingers touch the slender glass edges, then they brush over four small, crusty balls and a pile of fluffy strands that appear to be vegetables.
All is good until a little wandering lands my thumb squarely in a slightly gritty wetness that I quickly deduce is some sort of gravy.
Around me people begin yelling. "Crab!" "It must be some sort of crab cake!" "And a salad?" "What is this?"
It turns out the appetizer before us is codfish croquettes in a chipotle sauce with some greens on the side. Not that it would have been readily apparent to any of the 35 diners that night, however.
After all, we were surrounded by an impenetrable darkness.
We had ventured to Suba, a cookie-cutter hip restaurant on Manhattan's Lower East Side, for "Dinner in the Dark" - a meal in a pitch-black room that renders you so blind it can take a harrowing, groping expedition simply to find the bread basket.
The theory is because diners cannot see, they have to rely on their senses of taste and smell and can better focus on those aspects of the food before them. This dining trend has surfaced recently in France, Switzerland and Germany in addition to New York. In Cologne's Unsicht Bar, the entire 50-seat dining room is completely dark and reportedly is so popular there's a six-week wait for a table.
Mitchell Davis, director of publications at the James Beard Foundation, says there is current interest in trends like dining in the dark for a simple reason.
"Food has become banal," he says. "You read the food magazines and it's all about lovely lifestyles and picnics in Tuscany and Paris. People are interested in opening their minds to new experiences."
A few months ago, the Manhattan restaurant Papillon blindfolded diners and served sea urchin infused with herbs. (At the same dinner, waiters also handcuffed people and made them lap up their consomme, but that's another story.) Jerome A. Chasques, head of New York's Cosmo Party, an event-organizing network focused on singles, said he recently introduced his version of dinner in the dark so people could try a different dining experience.
"Your eyes can't help you, so you really have to find out what's on your plate with your mouth," he says. "You have to pay more attention to what you're eating."
Attention to details
Diners also have to pay attention to several other details that any regular restaurant meal wouldn't call for. For the full dinner-in-the-dark experience, we are advised to wear dark or mostly black to blend in, and to go with clothing that can be cleaned easily. And guests are reminded that the dining room has a moat - into which one diner accidentally flung his jacket when he tried to drape it over his chair.
At the restaurant, once the sea of black-clad yuppies has settled in, a manager proceeds to impart information crucial to our coming mission: The squat highball glass holds wine; the tall, slender one will hold water.
Then, steeling ourselves, we make our way to the entrance of a small room sealed off with thick, black curtains. Waiters surface wearing night-vision goggles that bear a certain gulf war je ne sais quoi. They take our hands and gently guide us to our seats.
In the dark, the first thing we notice is how incredibly loud everyone has gotten. We cannot see one another, and all the usual tools in the rituals of interaction - gesticulating, eye contact - are useless. Helplessness sets in when we realize we don't even know if there is bread on the table.
At first, there is pandemonium. Our eyes adjust to the darkness, but still, the room is a vast blackness bursting with strange yells and giggles. We find our glasses and hold onto them for dear life, terrified at the thought of losing them forever in the black void.
The short glass suddenly feels like our best friend.
Across from me is Hernan Amorini, a 26-year-old poet/writer/social-work administrator from Queens. The idea of having a heightened sense of taste intrigued him.
"I'm interested in seeing if, scientifically, it is true," he says eagerly. "Of course, I could blindfold myself at home and eat dinner, but it would not be the same."
At Suba, there is a four-course meal to be had - with the goggled waiters loudly announcing the arrival of each course before setting it down. We are not given knives, and soon enough, we learn that randomly spearing the plate with our forks isn't necessarily the most effective way of picking up food.
With the arrival of the first entree, diners have settled into a rhythm of thoughtful chewing followed by excited utterances. Occasionally, groups start banging their glasses on the table, screaming, "Wine! Wine! Wine!" and, naturally, a few spillages occur.
I bite into a soft, slightly rubbery oval with a long flap around it. There is a distinct salty smokiness in the outer layer that immediately suggests bacon, and the oval feels like a scallop. I feel triumphant, smart, even Martha-ian - well, until Amorini starts a discussion analyzing the spices in the sauce.
There is less luck with the second entree - a phyllo pastry topped with a very salty, shredded ... something. Chicken? Duck? Beef? The guesses span the usual farm animals. It is delicious - and turns out to be roast baby lamb with artichokes and tomatoes. It's good we found out after we ate - I would have attempted to pick out all the artichokes had I known they were there.
I wonder how valid the theory of heightened taste is. Rodney Taylor, assistant professor of otolaryngology at the University of Maryland Medical School, says studies have shown that the other senses of the visually impaired tend to be sharper.
"But the phenomenon of enhanced taste doesn't appear in a short-term period to seeing people who usually have the use of their eyes," Taylor says. "It's usually something that's developed over a period of time."
Some drawbacks
There are drawbacks to such meals in the dark - it can be hard to get the waiters' attention, for example, and there's little accountability. After one diner had asked for more wine for the fifth time, he muttered, "Of course, it's easy for the waiter to say he'll bring me more wine and then just not show up with it. I can't see which one he is!"
Confusion, too, can set in easily - but, sometimes, with amusing results. At one point during the dinner, Amorini had mixed up his glasses of red and white wine, and a waiter confessed he couldn't tell the difference either because he couldn't see color through his night-vision goggles. He then proceeded to grab one glass, take a swig and say, "This is red."
Nonetheless, diners at Suba felt their lights-out meal offered many pluses.
"I'm not a big seafood fan," says David Brown, 32, a commodities broker from Calgary. "But the fact that I was grabbing these little crab cakes and firing them into my mouth and going, 'It's really good. What is this?' - it's funny. Later, they said it was a cod ball, and I was just, like, 'Oh, cool.' "
Brendan Connellan, 32, a Morgan Stanley vice president, was thrilled with how everyone loosened up in the dark.
"There was no need to pose; it didn't matter how you were dressed because no one could see you," says Connellan, who lives in Manhattan.
"I threw bread at a girl across the table - I don't usually do that. I've never banged my glass on the table for more wine. You have the freedom to do stuff like that because you feel like people can't see."
By comparison, just 10 feet away, the main room in Suba was the picture of genteel dining with the soft hum of hushed conversations.
But in the dark, discussions easily sprang up among strangers. There were conversations about spices, the Spanish soccer league and the beauty of James Joyce.
Even after candles were brought in and we finally could see the faces, the clothes, the people, we simply dug into our butternut-squash ice cream.
And kept on talking.
The next dinner in the dark takes place Feb. 4 at Suba and is $89 per person. For more information, click on www.cosmoparty.com/dinner-in-the-dark.