SUBSCRIBE

Few seek a new school

THE BALTIMORE SUN

The federal government's plan to ease the way for families to move their children out of poorly performing public schools is likely to have little impact across the Baltimore region, with only a tiny fraction of eligible students expected to transfer.

Roughly 6,800 students in four suburban counties are eligible, but only 244 transfers have been requested, a survey of school officials shows.

In Baltimore, more than 30,000 students are eligible, but school officials have set aside only 194 places for possible transfers - a number denounced as inadequate by Michael Hamilton, president of the city's Council of PTAs. How many Baltimore parents will seek transfers for their children is unknown.

State school officials haven't determined how many students are seeking transfers across Maryland but they see no signs of an exodus this fall.

"From what we understand, it's fairly small," said Bill Reinhard, a spokesman with the state Department of Education.

Maryland has 118 low-income schools with test scores poor enough to participate in the transfer program established in the No Child Left Behind Act, signed by President Bush this year.

Under that law, school districts receiving federal money must allow parents to transfer their children from low-performing schools to schools scoring higher in standardized achievement tests. Local school systems also must pay for buses to carry the transferring students.

School officials suggest several reasons for the low participation in Baltimore's suburbs.

Parents might want to keep their children in neighborhood schools. Or they might recognize that transferring could mean missing out on the extra funding and resources available at poorly performing schools.

Moreover, many officials believe that the small number of transfer applications shows that parents are not so dissatisfied with public schools and will stick with a struggling school if it shows signs of improvement.

Howard County had 62 applications for transfers from six schools: Bryant Woods, Phelps Luck, Guilford, Dasher Green, Swansfield and Talbott Springs elementary schools. More than 2,000 Howard students were eligible.

The small number of applicants is "encouraging," said Ray Ellen Levene, Howard's Title I coordinator. "And what's interesting to me is that the schools that are starting to improve, they only had two or three students" apply.

The trend was similar across the region.

In Baltimore County, 92 out of 1,347 eligible pupils asked to be moved from Powhatan and Winfield elementary schools and Woodlawn Middle School.

In Anne Arundel, 77 applied for transfers from Freetown, Georgetown East, Harman, Tyler Heights and Van Bokkelen elementary schools - and 2,478 were eligible.

Thirteen children in Harford County asked to leave Hall's Cross Roads and Magnolia elementary schools - although nearly 1,000 were eligible.

No Carroll County schools have been struggling long enough to be covered by the law. But state officials say scores from the coming year's tests could push two schools - Robert Moton Elementary and Taneytown Elementary - over the edge if there's no improvement.

Area school systems are trying to determine the cost of the student transfers.

Under the new law, schools must set aside 15 percent of their federal Title I funding to provide transferring students with transportation.

Financial effects

Principals don't expect student departures to have a negative effect, although some Title I funds could be diverted from programs and staffing.

Harford County schoolchildren will probably take a bus to their home school, and a shuttle bus from there, a plan that won't have much impact on the home school's funding, said spokesman Don Morrison.

Earl Slacum, principal of Columbia's Swansfield Elementary School, doesn't expect an impact because none of the 11 children who applied for transfers from his school received free- or reduced-price lunch - meaning they weren't benefiting from Title I money.

In fact, 42 percent of the Howard County students who sought transfers were neither low-income nor low-performing - the very groups targeted by the new law. School officials say parents are seeking transfers for reasons other than academics.

"I guess these are just parents who are looking to open-enroll their kids, parents who are looking at putting them in a different environmental setting," school board Chairwoman Jane B. Schuchardt said. "It's not because the schools aren't providing them their needs."

In Baltimore County, officials haven't analyzed applications to say whether the lowest-income or poorest-performing students are taking advantage of the law.

Kimberley West, president of Powhatan Elementary's PTA, said the parents who requested transfers from Powhatan were involved with the school and were often the parents of better-performing pupils.

"These are the parents always looking for the best opportunities for their children," West said. Some would have sought transfers even without the new law, she added.

The impact of the transfers "will be minimal," said Baltimore County schools spokesman Charles Herndon. "We're talking about a very small number of students, even in those schools receiving the most students. Keep in mind these students will be spread out over grade levels, too."

194 spots in city

In Baltimore, school officials said they limited transfers because the schools designated to accept students were nearly full. They pointed out that only 22 students took advantage of a transfer option last year.

If more than 194 students apply to transfer, city school officials will randomly pick students to be transferred and will notify parents Aug. 12.

State education officials declined to comment last week on whether the city is meeting the requirements of the federal law. They plan to monitor the progress of each district.

At Anne Arundel's Park Elementary, Principal Diane Lenzi was surprised that two families asked to transfer out. She said other pupils have applied to transfer to the Brooklyn Park school, which has full-day kindergarten and summer reading and after-school reading programs. First- and second-grade classes have fewer than 20 children.

Lt. Gov. Kathleen Kennedy Townsend visited the school this year and was so impressed that she returned to tape a commercial for her gubernatorial campaign, Lenzi said.

"You can see why it's an attractive school," she said. "I'm shocked that two people want to leave here."

Sun staff writers Stephen Kiehl, Jonathan D. Rockoff, Liz Bowie and Jennifer McMenamin contributed to this article.

Copyright © 2021, The Baltimore Sun, a Baltimore Sun Media Group publication | Place an Ad

You've reached your monthly free article limit.

Get Unlimited Digital Access

4 weeks for only 99¢
Subscribe Now

Cancel Anytime

Already have digital access? Log in

Log out

Print subscriber? Activate digital access