An attorney for an 18-year-old man charged with attempted murder in one of two shootings that stunned Harper's Choice last September said yesterday the state arrested the wrong man.
In opening statements, the prosecution said Robert Joseph Manning fired a sawed-off shotgun and seriously wounded John Gordon Jackson, 38, just before 2 a.m. on Sept. 21 near Jackson's apartment on Harpers Farm Road. But defense attorney Richard Bernhardt named another man as the shooter.
Jackson, a disabled Army veteran, was shot about 24 hours after a 17-year-old boy was robbed and shot in the abdomen a block and a half away -- a crime for which another defendant is scheduled to go on trial.
Manning has been charged with attempted first- and second-degree murder, first- and second-degree assault and carrying a weapon with intent to injure. He could face a life sentence if convicted of attempted murder.
The prosecution called several witnesses to the stand, including Jackson, who now lives in North Carolina with his girlfriend and works for a temporary employment agency. Jackson testified that he had tried to buy cocaine from Manning the day of the shooting, but that the deal never took place.
Jackson later asked another acquaintance, Nathan Hicks, to "front" him some drugs. When Hicks said no, Jackson testified he offered to lend him his girlfriend's car, a Suzuki Esteem, in exchange for two $20 "rocks" of cocaine.
When Hicks hadn't returned the car by midnight, the specified time, Jackson went looking for him, he said. As he approached two people sitting on a bench behind the Fall River Terrace apartment complex in the 5500 block of Harpers Farm Road to ask if they had seen Hicks, Jackson said, someone shot him from behind a nearby Dumpster.
Jackson said he turned around and saw Manning with a shotgun.
After Manning and the two others, one of whom Jackson identified as Tavon Donya Sands, left the scene, Jackson made his way back to his apartment. There, according to his testimony, he knocked on the window and told his girlfriend, "Call 911. I've been shot."
Jackson's girlfriend, Hythern Audrey Walker, testified earlier in the day that Jackson had bought cocaine from Manning on prior occasions. She said she once gave Manning one of her rings in exchange for drugs.
Officer Douglas Catherman, who responded to the scene first, testified that Jackson identified the shooter that night as "Black," a nickname used by Manning, after first saying he didn't know who had shot him.
Catherman said he thought Jackson was referring to Roberto Joseph Brathwaite, who also uses the street name "Black," and whose driver's license was found that morning in Jackson's girlfriend's car after Hicks returned it.
According to his testimony, Catherman asked Jackson before he was flown to Maryland Shock Trauma Center if he meant Brathwaite, and Jackson said yes. Jackson said that "Black" was wearing his hair in dreadlocks and that he stayed at the nearby Abbott House apartment complex at the corner of Harpers Farm Road and Cedar Lane.
Manning often visited that high-rise, where his teen-age girlfriend, Shanae Griffiths, and their 13-month-old daughter, Shaquelle, lived, Griffiths told The Sun last year. Abbott House management had banned him from the property for a number of alleged infractions, including destruction of property.
Police searched Griffiths' apartment for "Black" that night, but found no one. Manning was arrested the next day.
In his opening statement, Bernhardt connected Jackson's shooting to the shooting the night before of Raymond Lawson, a 17-year-old from Wilde Lake, in the 5400 block of Harpers Farm Road, a block and a half away.
He said that Manning was present at the time of the Jackson shooting but that Sands pulled the trigger. Sands, he said, thought Jackson had been involved in Lawson's shooting and wanted to get back at him.
Pub Date: 3/03/99