Nowadays, most books - novels, biographies, even collections of short stories - are far too fat for their own good. But I have always had a special place in my heart and on my shelves for a certain kind of big book: the crotchety, opinionated work of reference by an author (or editor) who knows everything worth knowing about his particular area of expertise, and has boiled it down to small, readily digestible bits of savory prose.
The best such books can be read straight through from end to end, but they are also ideal for bedtime consumption, since they can be dipped into at random and read with profit for a few minutes, then put aside until the next sleepless night.
Many such books have turned up from time to time in the course of this series, but the present list consists exclusively of titles that have never before been featured in an "Instant Culture" piece. All are readily available at your neighborhood bookstore or online, and all are highly suitable for anyone wishing to further his self-education in the best of all possible ways - reading.
The books pages of The Sun do not publish Christmas lists as such. But should you find yourself in search of just the right present for a bookish friend, my guess is that any of them would fill the bill quite neatly:
* Movies. David Thomson's "Biographical Dictionary of Film" (Knopf, 834 pages, $27.50 paper) is a spectacularly biased compilation of more than 1,000 short essays covering most of the film industry's key figures.
What Thomson loves, he loves passionately; what he loathes, he nails to the wall. Either way, the things he has to say are guaranteed to make you think twice about actors and directors whose work you thought you knew like the back of your hand.
Here, for example, is Thomson on Humphrey Bogart: "He made few wholly satisfactory films - 'High Sierra,' 'To Have and Have Not,' 'The Big Sleep,' 'In a Lonely Place' - and failed in a variety of parts outside the narrow range he saw fit for himself. But within that range he had the impact of Garbo or James Dean. Like them, he was a Romantic. It is harder to see him as such because of the efforts he made to appear anti-Romantic. The implications of his work - as a comment on self-dramatization - are rather more daunting and disturbing than he ever realized."
* Ballet. Robert Greskovic's "Ballet 101: A Complete Guide to Learning and Loving the Ballet" (Hyperion, 634 pages, $16.95 paper) is far and away the best and most comprehensive introductory guide to classical ballet. Greskovic, a much-admired New York critic who recently began covering dance for the Wall Street Journal, is a true expert who has never lost his enthusiasm for ballet, and he writes about it with all the infectious enthusiasm of a first-time dancegoer. Of special value are his detailed descriptions of 14 major ballets, all keyed to currently available videocassette versions - a brilliant idea, brilliantly executed.
* Radio. John Dunning's newly published "On the Air: The Encyclopedia of Old-Time Radio" (Oxford, 822 pages, $55) is the long-awaited second edition of "Tune In Yesterday," the definitive guide to network radio, which has been out of print for years (used copies sell for up to $200 apiece). This extensively revised version, which contains twice as many entries as its predecessor, is packed with crisply written miniature essays on the classic shows of yesteryear.
"Vic and Sade," "Fibber McGee and Molly," "Information, Please," "The Shadow," "I Love a Mystery," "One Man's Family" - all are described in evocative and reliable detail. Dunning is no mere nostalgia hound, and he frequently passes unsparing judgments some of radio's best-loved series (he's unexpectedly tough, for instance, on Bob Hope and Fred Allen).
Warning: Reading this book is likely to make you want to go out and buy a couple of dozen "Jack Benny Program" cassettes.
* Literature. H. L. Mencken's "New Dictionary of Quotations" (Knopf, 1347 pages, $75) began life as a card file of Mencken's favorite quotations, gradually metamorphosing into a more formal but no less lively affair.
According to the flap copy, which sounds suspiciously as though Mencken had a hand in it, the "New Dictionary" "is planned on strictly historical principles, with every possible quotation dated....It omits mere platitudes, and confines itself to authors who had something to say and said it to good effect. But all the immemorial tags and scraps of human wisdom have been included, and special attention is given to the great proverbs of every civilization." (In fact, some of those so-called "proverbs" were home-cooked by none other than H. L. Mencken himself.) Not surprisingly, the finished product is strongly biased in favor of quotations that are witty, cynical or disillusioned.
* Country music. Paul Kingsbury's new "Enyclopedia of Country Music" (Oxford, 634 pages, $49.95), compiled by the staff of Nashville's Country Music Hall of Fame and Museum, sets new standards in the field.
Though some of the entries are considerably less critical than others (the ones dealing with artists of the '90s tend to be superficial), the key figures of country music are all treated concisely and responsibily, in many cases by such leading scholars as Bill C. Malone, Nolan Porterfield and Neil V. Rosenberg.
* Philosophy. Few subjects strike as much fear into the hearts of ordinary readers as does philosophy, and most "introductory" treatments sow more confusion than they clear up. Not so Ted Honderlich's "Oxford Companion to Philosophy" (Oxford, 1,009 pages, $49.95), which is without doubt the very finest single-volume dictionary of philosophy ever published.
The 249 contributors, among whom are numbered such distinguished philosophers as Isaiah Berlin, Alasdair MacIntyre and Michael Walzer, have produced 2,000-odd entries that are mostly short and invariably to the point, and the cross-references are consistently helpful.
The results live up to Honderlich's stated goals: "The book is for all those who want authoritative enlightenment, judgment by good judges. Thus it is directed partly to general readers for whom philosophy has a fascination greater than or at least as great as any other part of our intellectual and cultural existence, and who want accounts of it that they can trust. The book is also directed to those who study and practice the subject, and are scrupulous about their guides. If it did not also have the second aim, it could not have the first. No accounts of a subject can be authoritative for the general reader if they do not also attract and aim to survive the scrutiny of its readers."
* Art. Robert Hughes' "American Visions: The Epic History of Art in America" (Knopf, 635 pages, $65), published earlier this year, has been blasted by scholars for offenses ranging from triviality to plagiarism. But while it isn't perfect, you'll look a long time before finding a more exciting book about art.
Hughes flies his prejudices like a battle pennant, and isn't afraid to be funny, a commodity rarely in evidence among the jargon-gnawing Marxists who currently dominate American art criticism. Here, for example, is his devastating last word on Andy Warhol: "He matched the 1980s, and was in perfect sync with their greed, their puffery, their rampant pursuit of status through art. As Sir Thomas Beecham said when the elephant crapped on the stage during rehearsals for 'Aida': what a critic!"
Terry Teachout, author of The Sun's "Instant Culture" occasional series, is the music critic of Commentary and a contributing writer for Time magazine. He also writes about the arts for the New York Times, the Wall Street Journal, National Review and other publications. The editor of "A Second Mencken Chrestomathy" (Knopf), he is currently at work on "H. L. Mencken: A Life," to be published by Simon & Schuster.
Pub Date: 11/29/98