A 'legislative craftsman' walks away from his trade After 35 years, Dole leaves a legacy as a consensus builder; CAMPAIGN 1996

WASHINGTON — WASHINGTON -- Bob Dole's champions wince when he lists as his greatest Senate achievement the 1983 compromise he struck with New York Democrat Daniel Patrick Moynihan to save the Social Security system from bankruptcy.

That last-minute deal raised taxes, cut benefits, was brokered in a back room and didn't have Dole's name on it. Not great stuff for a presidential campaign ad.


But as the Kansas Republican leaves Congress tomorrow after 35 years, the rescue of Social Security ranks high among many tales of legislative derring-do that illustrate what Bob Dole does best: reach beyond party and ideology to bring order from the chaos of competing egos and conflicting interests.

He listens, he waits, he pushes, he pulls, he gets angry, he jokes away the tension, but he never gives up. The Senate Republican leader's fingerprints are all over nearly every important law passed in the last dozen years -- from budgets, taxes and farm measures, to civil rights, defense and foreign policy.


"He's a master legislative craftsman, and the best vote counter I've ever seen," says California Gov. Pete Wilson. As a member of the Senate in 1985, Wilson was wheeled into the Senate chamber on a hospital gurney at 1: 30 a.m., shortly after undergoing an emergency appendectomy, to cast a critical vote at Dole's request. "In a way, it's a shame he's a candidate for president."

Some colleagues wept when Dole, 72, announced last month that he was resigning to run full time for the White House. Their tears testified to how far Dole has come from the hot-headed stridence of his freshman days in the 1960s. He departs as a senior statesman, widely respected by his adversaries and regarded with deep affection by his friends.

"It's been an extraordinary career, and an extraordinarily positive one," says Norman Ornstein, a congressional scholar at the American Enterprise Institute. "At the end of the

century, when they put together a Hall of Fame or a Top 10 list for the Senate, Bob Dole's name will be there."

The last few months of partisan rivalry between Dole and President Clinton chilled some warm feelings for Dole on the Democratic side. Leading a GOP-controlled Congress for the first time, Dole has shown less flexibility as he tried to shore up support among the party's right wing.

Yet he continues to be admired.

"I think he's a remarkable leader," declares Nebraska Democrat Bob Kerrey, who said Dole has often been "willing to risk a great deal [and go] against public opinion."

Tough beginning


Dole had some rocky years at the start.

"When I first came to Congress, I was way out in right field," Dole told reporters in a recent session aboard his campaign plane. "I was very conservative except for farm subsidies."

Like the soldier he once was, Dole also came to Congress willing to inflict casualties when he considered the cause just. He gained a reputation as a hatchet man defending President Richard Nixon's policies on Vietnam and two doomed Supreme Court nominations. Dole's floor debates with Sen. George McGovern, the South Dakota Democrat, set a standard for harshness rarely matched since.

At the time, then-Sen. William Saxbe of Ohio -- an anti-war Republican -- declared Dole to be so disliked "he couldn't sell beer on a troopship."

Colleagues say Dole seemed embittered by his World War II injuries and was almost prudish in his Midwestern reserve. No ribald jokes, no after-hours drinking, not much tolerance for such behavior in others.

But over the years, Dole mellowed, particularly after his 1975 marriage to his second wife, Elizabeth.


"I always said that Liz Dole took off the rough edges," says Sen. Edward M. Kennedy, a Massachusetts Democrat and one of a handful of senators who have served longer than Dole.

The legislative game

Dole learned well the rhythms of the legislative process and how to look into the hearts of his fellow lawmakers to understand their motivations. He became a gifted broker of compromises, a consensus builder more interested in results than holding out for an elusive principle.

He found himself working with McGovern to create the food stamp program, with Moynihan on tax and health care bills, and Kennedy on civil rights legislation -- particularly a measure imposing sweeping new requirements on businesses to provide access for the disabled.

"I think I became more national," he says of his metamorphosis.

Democrats came to trust him as a man of his word. Republicans chose him as their leader 11 years ago and kept him on longer than any GOP leader in Senate history.


"He has a knack for knowing when to give in, but holding out as long as possible for the best deal," says Democrat Robert C. Byrd of West Virginia, who like Dole served as both majority leader and minority leader and was often on the opposite side of the bargaining table from him.

The value of this talent in the Senate can't be overstated. Ground rules for every action -- even such simple matters as the schedule for debate -- have to be negotiated, and every senator must agree.

Dole's leadership has sometimes been characterized by hardball tactics.

As majority leader in 1985, he locked a bill imposing sanctions on South Africa in a safe so it couldn't be voted on. And as minority leader in 1994, Dole crushed much of the Clinton legislative agenda by refusing to allow it to come up for a vote.

But new senators soon learned that Dole's dark, imposing presence -- enhanced by thick eyebrows and stern looks -- disguised a soft heart and a wry, if occasionally caustic, sense of humor.

Much of Dole's voting record reflects his early conservatism. As a member of the House of Representatives during the 1960s, for example, he voted against the creation of the Medicare system.


But after moving to the Senate in 1969, he took a more centrist approach in the policy areas that most interested him.

"He is very broad-minded on civil rights questions, for example," says former Sen. Charles McC. Mathias, a Maryland Republican who arrived in the House with Dole in 1961 and moved to the Senate with him in 1969.

But he played vital, behind-the-scenes roles on every civil rights bill passed over the past 15 years, usually working to soften the resistance of Republican Presidents Ronald Reagan and George Bush.

"He would thread the needle to get the bills through," recalls Ralph Neas, who saw these Dole maneuvers firsthand as chief lobbyist for the Leadership Conference on Civil Rights.

Typical of Dole's intervention was a 1991 trip to the White House in which he persuaded Bush not to oppose a measure designed to curb discrimination in hiring. Dole's tactic that day: taking along a group of GOP senators who told the president they would not support his veto.

Balancing the federal budget has been a top priority for Dole, a traditional economic conservative, and until recently he's been willing to raise taxes to do it.


As chairman of the Senate Finance Committee in 1982, he helped persuade his colleagues, and Reagan, to accept a huge tax increase to shrink the budget gap left by the Reagan tax cuts of the year before.

At the time, the '82 tax increase was the largest in American history, and measured in today's dollars, it still is.

In 1990, Dole stood by Bush -- and against House Republicans led by Newt Gingrich -- to forge a controversial budget deal that included an increase in gasoline taxes. This year, however, he pushed for the rollback of another, smaller gas tax increase -- the one Clinton succeeded in getting Congress to approve in 1993.

During his career, Dole was less interested than others in wasteful, pork-barrel spending projects. But in one of his final Senate deals, he and Kennedy interrupted a floor fight over the minimum wage to permit speedy passage of measures designed to create new recreation areas: one in Kansas, the other in Massachusetts.

"We were right in the thick of it," Kennedy recalls, "when I approached Bob and said, 'Why don't we do one more for the Republicans, and one more for the Democrats?' He said, 'Whose?' and I said, 'Yours.' He said, 'Whose for the other side?' I said, 'Mine.' He said, 'Sounds good.' "

Probably the easiest deal he ever made.


Pub Date: 6/10/96