Voters not keen on race for judges Many unable to name any of 5 candidates


Howard County politicians and attorneys are following intensely the primary campaign for two county Circuit Court seats, but so far the acrimonious race is barely registering with the electorate. Mos interviews with a sampling of county residents.

In about 65 such interviews with Sun reporters during the past 1 1/2 weeks, few prospective Howard voters could name any of the candidates without prompting.

The response of Greta Stockman, 38, of North Laurel was typical: "There are a man and woman who are running and are talking bad about the other two women that are running."

Added Brian Harvey, 32, of Laurel: "Ito and Wapner are the only two judges anybody knows," referring to the O. J. Simpson trial judge and the televised "People's Court" judge.

At the same time, many county voters -- even those who know little about the judges race now -- say that picking good jurists is increasingly important to them because of their growing concern about crime.

"We need somebody to crack down on these people," John Hol-brook, a Columbia man said while having breakfast with his wife at Frank's Place in Jessup.

As the March 5 primary draws closer, four of the five candidates for the two Circuit Court seats are poised to spend heavily on advertising -- particularly local cable TV ads -- in an effort to transform that general concern into concrete choices in the voting booth.

One of the challengers in the race, Columbia resident and Pikesville attorney Jay Fred Cohen, has raised little money and promises a low-key finish to his low-key campaign.

But the other two challengers -- District Judge Lenore R. Gelfman and attorney Jonathan Scott Smith -- can be counted upon to increasingly hammer away at their central campaign theme: that they are more experienced than the two sitting judges appointed last fall by Gov. Parris N. Glendening.

First woman and first black

The appointed Circuit Court judges -- Diane O. Leasure and Donna Hill Staton -- were sworn into office in November. They are, respectively, the first woman and the first black person to serve as Howard Circuit judges.

The Gelfman-Smith camp has disparaged Judges Leasure and Hill Staton with allegations that they lack sufficient criminal law experience and by referring to their short time on the bench as "training wheels."

Supporters of Judges Leasure and Hill Staton, in turn, have cast the two challengers as "whiners" whose central complaint is that the governor passed them by in the judicial selection process.

Their campaign techniques so far have differed.

Judge Gelfman and Mr. Smith have been using the tried-and-true tactic of standing by major county intersections during the morning rush hour to wave at prospective voters.

They also have decorated the sides of county roadways with placards and intend to "blitz" various parts of the county with pamphlets.

"You're always going to have the voter who doesn't read the newspaper and doesn't know about the campaign," said Chevy Fleischman, the Gelfman-Smith spokeswoman. "We will reach out to them."

By contrast, the appointed judges have been more sedate, perhaps in an effort to emphasize that they already sit on the bench. But their camp also is beginning to plaster the sides of major roads with signs and to mail pamphlets.

Lin Eagan, manager of the Leasure-Hill Staton campaign, said the sitting judges' message is that they have strong educational and legal backgrounds -- and that their opponents have offered no reason for change.

Glendening a factor for some

For a small but notable core of voters sampled by The Sun, Mr. Glendening's appointment of the sitting judges appears to be a negative factor.

"We don't know a whole lot but we know this much," said Doris Redding at Columbia's Kings Contrivance Village Center. "We're not going to vote for the ones Glendening put in."

At Columbia's Dorsey's Search Village Center, Lory Thompson also was upset by the governor's stated intention of increasing the court's diversity.

"I don't like quotas for quotas' sake," he said.

"I don't think judges should be political appointees at any level. I'm a Democrat, but Glendening is not a favorite person with me."

But some others interviewed like the idea of more diversity on the bench.

"We need black women judges," Rachel Wade said at Columbia's Hickory Ridge Village Center.

And along Ellicott City's Main Street, store clerk Elizabeth Mallon said she favors Judges Leasure and Hill Staton: "We need more women on the bench. I don't even know what their political affiliation is and it doesn't matter to me."

Experience is stressed

Judge Gelfman and Mr. Smith are trying to overcome such leanings by stressing their experience.

At Dorsey's Search, Dwayne McElrath said he's heard that line of reasoning but he is convinced the movement toward diversity is more important.

"Qualifications are important," he said, "but it's time for a change. Where do you start? Where do you begin? When you make a change, you can't please everybody. This is our chance."

But experience does matter for Ruth Moody, who stopped at Dorsey's Search.

She said she received a phone call from the Gelfman-Smith team and that it made an impression on her.

"They were making a big problem out of the fact that the others don't have a crime background -- and it does concern me," Ms. Moody said.

"I will pursue that before I vote."

Nevertheless, the vast majority of prospective voters interviewed acknowledged that they haven't begun to think about the judges race.

40% turnout predicted

The county Board of Elections expects only about 40 percent of registered voters to cast ballots in the primary, and it's likely that many won't be familiar with the candidates by March 5 -- despite the increasingly feverish campaign.

In Lisbon, for example, the community's self-described unofficial mayor, Dorothy Gray, notes that the daily talk at her grocery store has not touched on the campaign.

"The guys talk about plenty of stuff," she said, "but I haven't heard of anything about that."

Robert Costello, 34, owner of E. C. Does It Cafe on Main Street in Ellicott City, said it's difficult voting in judges races because "we can't pull out their records." He dismissed the vitriolic tone of the campaign as just "politics as usual."

Or, as Sue Bell, 39, at Joe Bell's Body Shop in Dayton, put it: "Nobody's interested."

Copyright © 2019, The Baltimore Sun, a Baltimore Sun Media Group publication | Place an Ad