Nobody could possibly dial a phone as quickly as new Orioles general manager Pat Gillick, said farm director Syd Thrift. He has hundreds of phone numbers memorized, and as he ends one conversation, Gillick already has his index finger moving to the buttons. An amazing thing to watch, Thrift said.
Gillick went to Florida on Dec. 11, and he and Johnson met
with Leiter and with Torres, Alomar's agent. Gillick came away feeling good about his chances of signing Leiter, although the bidding was progressing at an extraordinary rate: The Orioles' three-year offer had increased from $5.5 million to $8.6 million.
But shortly after midnight the morning of Dec. 15, Leiter's agent woke up Florida GM Dave Dombrowski at home to tell him the pitcher wanted to sign with the Marlins.
Gillick looked depressed as he announced the signing of Myers the next day. He had wanted Leiter badly. "Well," he said determinedly that afternoon, "we'll get somebody else."
They did. Gillick had talked with Atlanta GM John Schuerholz about Mercker, and on Dec. 16, Schuerholz told Gillick he wanted two prospects -- reliever Joe Borowski and left-hander Rachaad Stewart.
Thrift agonized over surrendering Stewart. Gillick tried to replace Stewart in the trade, but Schuerholz said no Stewart, no deal.
Gillick wanted to do the deal as quickly as possible for reasons of logistics: Schuerholz was at a Mexican hideaway on a fishing trip with Braves manager Bobby Cox, and Gillick figured no other major-league GM would know where to contact Schuerholz. He wanted to finish the trade before Schuerholz returned to his office Dec. 18 and began calling around to other clubs to deal Mercker. At 9 p.m. on Dec. 17, Gillick and Schuerholz swapped pitchers.
Molitor gets the assist
Whether or not they signed Molitor to play third, Gillick wanted Surhoff, a versatile player coming off the best year of his career. Surhoff could move to the outfield, catch, DH -- whatever the Orioles needed. And Gillick knew that Surhoff's wife, Polly Winde, was from the Baltimore area.
Leaving Milwaukee would be hard for Surhoff. The Brewers made Surhoff a three-year offer, improved it to four years, and planned to plaster his picture on the cover of their media guide. Surhoff fretted, too, over matters of family: One of the Surhoffs' sons has a form of autism, and they would have to find a school here comparable to the one he attended in Milwaukee. (This is a primary reason Surhoff asked the Orioles for a full no-trade clause.)
The Surhoffs found such a school after traveling to Baltimore on Dec. 15. Some close to him encouraged him to sign with the Orioles. But Surhoff continued to weigh his allegiance to the Brewers, and delayed his decision.
Gillick had seen this situation before, with Molitor after the 1992 season. Molitor fretted before finally leaving the Brewers -- a decision he ultimately would feel good about. Gillick, sure that Milwaukee owner Bud Selig was playing to Surhoff's sympathies, played his own trump card: He asked Molitor to call his good friend Surhoff and offer some advice.
Molitor did so, and on Dec. 20, Surhoff left the Brewers to sign a three-year deal with the Orioles.
McDonald rejects $2.8M
The Orioles executives decided early on that they wanted Ben McDonald back. The former No. 1 pick had a history with the team, and he was well-liked by other players. In September, Cal Ripken, the most influential member of the organization, said the Orioles should re-sign McDonald.
However, their medical reports indicated McDonald had suffered slight tear in his rotator cuff -- the type of injury many others had pitched through, but still a concern. And McDonald was coming off a season in which he had won three games. Gillick determined he would retain McDonald only if the price was right.
McDonald's salary in 1995 was $4.5 million, and McDonald's agent, Scott Boras, asked for $3.3 million plus incentive clauses that would allow McDonald to reach $4.5 million. Too high for Gillick. On Dec. 20, Gillick called Boras to tell him the Orioles would not tender McDonald a contract for 1996, effectively releasing the pitcher. Boras responded with 30 seconds of silence.
At some point during the next 48 hours, McDonald called Angelos and told him how much he liked playing for the Orioles, how he wanted to finish his career in Baltimore. Angelos had always liked McDonald's enthusiasm, and had a soft spot for the pitcher.
zTC Gillick offered McDonald a $2.8 million deal, with incentives to reach about $3.5 million. But, Gillick said, Boras held to his request for $3.3 million, with incentives to reach $4.5 million. As far as Gillick was concerned, it was time to look elsewhere for the last starter to fill out the rotation.
Cone gets away
Angelos had returned from his overseas trip Dec. 17, and shortly afterward he talked with Gillick. At that point, they revised the projected 1996 budget, from $40 million-$42 million to $46 million-$47 million; other teams were spending a lot more money than the Orioles anticipated.
The next day, Gillick and Thrift called Angelos, on speakerphone, to tell him they had two balls in the air -- three-year offers to Alomar and Cone. "Which one should we catch?" Gillick asked Angelos.
"Both of them," Angelos replied, and Gillick and Thrift laughed until they realized Angelos was serious.
By Dec. 20, Gillick was in serious negotiations with Cone and Alomar, and turned over the Alomar negotiations to Angelos. (The thought occurred to Gillick that Angelos' stance against replacement players last spring may have made him appealing to free agents this year.) Vice chairman Joe Foss and Robert Ames, the club's accountant, jumped into the talks to work out details on deferred money.
That night, Gillick thought he may have Cone. Then Cone's agent, Steve Fehr, said, "We'll think about it overnight."
Those overnight things never seem to work out, Gillick thought.
They did with Alomar: His agent and Angelos worked out a contract the next morning, and Thrift was sent to call Cone and tell him Alomar had signed. But when Gillick had trouble reaching Cone's agent early that afternoon, they knew Cone was re-signing with the Yankees.
Wrapping up with Wells
With Cone and McDonald out of the picture, and Kenny Rogers and Chuck Finley seeking big-money deals, Gillick began talking seriously to Cincinnati GM Jim Bowden about Wells. Bowden had to slash payroll, and Wells was set to make $3 million in 1996.
Bowden wanted minor-league pitcher Calvin Maduro, but Gillick didn't want to lose the right-hander. Then Bowden began asking about outfielders, and that led to the discussion of Curtis Goodwin.
The scouting staff was reluctant to deal Goodwin because of his exceptional speed. Those closer to the major-league team, who had seen Goodwin play in the majors and frustrate the big-league coaching staff with his stubborn refusal to take pitches, were ready to make the deal. Gillick and Bowden agreed to the parameters of the deal Dec. 23, and completed the trade the morning after Christmas.
In 29 days, the Orioles had acquired two quality starters, a closer, an All-Star second baseman, a .300 hitter, reliever Roger McDowell and utility man Bill Ripken. Pat Gillick, the speed-dialer, stayed home for the holidays.