SUBSCRIBE

Thanos: Never Far from Trouble THE EXECUTION OF JOHN THANOS

THE BALTIMORE SUN

I watched John Frederick Thanos die last week.

He went quietly, without a last-second outburst or change of heart. He looked toward the ceiling, his eyes fluttered, his mouth dropped open, and he was asleep. Death took him moments later.

As a criminal, John Thanos achieved more fame than he ever could have as a law-abiding citizen -- something he never was. From the age of 12, until his death at 45, Thanos was never far from trouble -- most, if not all of it, of his own making.

His crimes were brutal -- he executed three teen-agers with a sawed-off .22 caliber semi-automatic rifle which he carried around Maryland in a leather doctor's bag. He calmly confessed to his crimes while smoking a cigarette, and while complaining that police failed to kill him.

"I just wanted the basics to keep me alive so I could kill until they could kill me," Thanos said in his videotaped confessions. "And goddamn, I'm still alive and in pain."

Thanos was executed for the robbery and murder of Gregory A. Taylor Jr., 18, a welder from Hebron who had given John Thanos a ride. For a moment, he almost did not kill Taylor " 'cause he seemed so innocent." But "my twisted mind was twisting and I said, 'What the hell? What does it matter?' "

At the time of his execution, Thanos was also facing death for the murder of Billy Winebrenner, 16, and Melody Pistorio, 14, two Middle River teen-agers Thanos killed after robbing them of cash Sept. 3, 1990. He killed them despite the fact that they put up no resistance and treated him "perfectly good."

His confessions were sickeningly detailed, describing how many shots he put into each victim and how he spat on his gun afterward to wipe off the blood that splattered. He showed no remorse from the time of his arrest through his trials, sentencing hearings and ultimately his execution.

At one point, he lectured a Garrett County jury on religion. Later, when facing a death sentence, he went to extremes to demonstrate his lack of remorse, claiming he would like to bring his victims back to kill them again, then dig up their bones and crush them. He claimed to be sowing seeds of hate from his prison cell.

Yet Thanos was not always vile in his antics.

In court, he often demonstrated a quick wit, and could turn a clever phrase. He not only shocked judges, lawyers and courtroom observers with venomous statements, but he made them laugh, too.

He always denied that he enjoyed the attention he got in court, but he acted like a class clown. You could see him studying the judge, and he would often wait for the judge to look down or away before he said something or made a gesture.

Sometimes, it seemed he had changed very little since Baltimore County officials grew tired of his act in 1964 and sent him, at age 15 and weighing only 120 pounds, to an adult prison in Hagerstown for stealing a car.

Over the next 30 years, he would spend less than one year in freedom. His crimes grew worse.

In 1969, he raped a woman in Rosedale, and was given a 21-year prison sentence -- and he served almost all of it before being released in 1986.

A month later, he was back in prison on an armed robbery charge -- the sentence he was serving when he was released 18 months early by mistake in April of 1990. In the late 1980s, he did take two semesters of college at the Eastern Correctional Institute, getting good grades.

He developed a passion for writing. He showed some talent, too. His letters and poems were all carefully printed in his neat handwriting.

There were never any cross-outs, and few spelling or grammatical mistakes. He took care in his writing.

What he actually said in many of his letters was often bizarre, and sometimes obscene, but it was obvious he worked hard at expressing himself creatively, and that he enjoyed it.

"Around here," he wrote in January 1990, "I'm known as the Hound of Hell./I brew an evil potion, cast a wicked spell./Some call me beezlebub, others call me Satan./A Demon no doubt, be not mistaken./I come from down deep, call it Hell's Hole./Heaven can't match my bounty of souls."

The expression of an earnest belief that he had supernatural powers, a clear sign of mental illness? Or just a writer playing with words?

In June 1992, given the chance to apologize or beg for mercy, Thanos shocked the packed courtroom with what must rank as the top anti-apology of all time.

He read from pages of notes he had written, in anticipation of giving his allocution.

"There is no innocent people in this world, as far as I'm concerned," he said. "I know how to hurt people. I take the things away they love, and if people go back and start checking around, anybody that comes into contact with me, will see that there is a trail of tragedies that always befall the things they love and they can point the finger at me and I accept it proudly."

Later, in a letter complaining about efforts people were making to save his life, Thanos wrote, "My anger dissolves rather quickly. . . . I forgive practically, you might say, before the offense occurs. . . . I don't carry that sort of baggage, hate, tho I mimic it expertly to shock one into a thought to edify their foul spirit."

Recently, he wrote to his mother, and said, "Truths are simplistic" but lies are "complex and twisted, hard to comprehend."

In several letters to me, Thanos expressed his love of truth and his disdain of lies. "I am persuaded to abolish the Law and establish traditionally opposed truth in its pure state to quell my sore spirit in my particular space and time."

He chastised me for having printed lies that were told about him in court -- the stories of his traumatic childhood, the abuse he endured in prison, etc.

Yet, when asked for the truth, when asked to sit down and give a "correct" account of his life, Thanos always declined. He said he didn't need or want to be interviewed, said he had turned down cash offers for interviews.

"I'm not interested in setting the record straight," he wrote in November 1992. "I'm not a publicity hound."

Yet, in the same letter, he asked for $200 for an interview, money I declined to send. It's against Sun policy to pay for interviews, and criminals are not supposed to profit from their crimes.

Later, Thanos would write to say the $200 interview offer was bogus, a joke designed to get back at me for printing lies about him. To the end, he refused all interview requests -- yet he wrote volumes of letters.

He liked to speak his mind -- even to the point where Garrett County Judge Fred A. Thayer once threatened to gag him -- but he never granted an interview with a reporter.

It wasn't always the case. Early on in his first murder trial, it was obvious Thanos wanted desperately to be interviewed by reporters. He constantly tried to make contact with reporters and complained bitterly in court that his lawyers were keeping him from talking to the press.

All that changed after evidence of his abusive childhood and early incarceration in prison was introduced in court. From that point on, he complained about how lies were being told about him, and then repeated by the media, but declined to be interviewed.

Once the facts of his life were made known in court, it was as if his only defense was to deny them. He had no interest from then on in talking about himself.

Another aspect of him was his threatening, macho posturing. He bragged he'd never lost a fight in his life -- despite evidence to the contrary -- and often threatened to kill again. He talked about casting cancerous spells on people, as well.

But out of the spotlight, back in the small isolated cell at the Maryland Correctional Adjustment Center -- the so-called Supermax -- Thanos was entirely different. He was described as soft-spoken, kind -- even gentle -- by those who have had long conversations with him.

He wrote a lot about autonomy and control -- how he did not want anyone to threaten his autonomy or to take control away from him.

In the courtroom, he could say what he wanted, without fear that a reporter might ask an embarrassing follow-up question to what he said.

By refusing to be interviewed, and also by refusing to "engage in the judicial process," Thanos took control of his life.

@4 Glenn Small is a reporter for The Baltimore Sun.

Copyright © 2021, The Baltimore Sun, a Baltimore Sun Media Group publication | Place an Ad

You've reached your monthly free article limit.

Get Unlimited Digital Access

4 weeks for only 99¢
Subscribe Now

Cancel Anytime

Already have digital access? Log in

Log out

Print subscriber? Activate digital access