People Read, Cows Don't


If Carroll County Commissioner Donald I. Dell had been King Solomon, the story of the two women fighting over a baby would have had a much different ending. In the Biblical story, King Solomon's suggestion to divide the baby and give each of the women half prompted the baby's real mother to say she would rather lose her child than see it killed. If we can extrapolate from Mr. Dell's solution for locating the northwest library branch, he would have split the infant right down the middle.

The mayors of Union Bridge and New Windsor each want the branch library located in their town. The plain fact is that Carroll cannot afford to build two libraries. Since one of these two deserving towns will not get the branch library, Mr. Dell believes the solution is to deny each of the towns and build the branch midway between them in Linwood.

While Mr. Dell's solution has an appearance of fairness and equity, its underlying premise is simplistic and short-sighted. Libraries are in the service business. If they are doing a good job, their patrons borrow large numbers of books, magazines, records, videos and tapes. If libraries are to be well-patronized, they must be accessible. That is why libraries usually are located near large concentrations of people who can drive, bike or walk to these branches.

Locating a library that may cost more than $500,000 in a country village like Linwood does not make any more sense than locating a Wal-Mart or a McDonald's there. With a population of less than 100, Linwood might be home to more cows than people. In order to visit this branch, the several thousand residents of New Windsor and Union Bridge would have to get in their cars and drive. While the distance might be shorter than the current trip to the Westminster or Taneytown libraries, a Linwood branch, for all intents and purposes, still would be equally inaccessible.

We can sympathize with Commissioner Dell. In choosing between Union Bridge and New Windsor, the commissioners invariably will alienate the residents of the town without the library. But the reality is that locating this branch library is one of those tough decisions elected officials occasionally must make. Putting the proposed library in Linwood would be politically cowardly and wrong.

Copyright © 2019, The Baltimore Sun, a Baltimore Sun Media Group publication | Place an Ad