Schilling shows what counts most is quality, not quantity, of pitches 146-pitch shutout saves bullpen, Phils


TORONTO -- Wrapping up a World Series in a brown paper bag for the working man (second shift):

Without qualification, here's a vote for Curt Schilling as baseball's Man of the Year. Why Schilling?

It says here that Schilling did more to revolutionize baseball in Game 5 of the World Series than all the pitch-counters in the game's history. He's not the first, of course, but he certainly is the most recent to be allowed to prove the point. And he gets added points for doing so under the stress and strain of a win-or-else game in the World Series.

Less than 24 hours after the Phillies and Blue Jays combined for 32 hits and 29 runs, Schilling pitched what many would describe as a masterpiece. He beat the Blue Jays, 2-0, just the second time all year that the American League champions had been shut out (you know by now that Fernando Valenzuela authored the other).

It took Schilling 146 pitches to complete (a rarity these days) his job. It's a good thing he wasn't on a pitch count. If he had been, judging by events of the night before, the Phillies could've gone golfing a few days earlier.

After the seventh inning, Phillies manager Jim Fregosi said he asked pitching coach Johnny Podres how many pitches Schilling had thrown. Told the count had surpassed 130, Fregosi said: "Let me know when he hits 150 . . . or 160."

What Fregosi meant was: "If he runs out of gas, so do we." There would be no bullpen torchlight parade that night. The Phillies had a horse on the mound and they were going to ride him to the finish.

Which doesn't, or shouldn't, seem all that unusual. Baseball games have always been decided by the quality, not the quantity, of pitches thrown.

But somewhere along the line, and it hasn't been that long ago, baseball got caught up in a fixation that says more than 100 pitches is stretching the limit. Strangely -- and perhaps wrongly -- this "discovery" came about shortly after it was determined pitchers needed four days of rest instead of three. Thus was born the five-man starting rotation, the best description of which still belongs to ex-Orioles pitching coach George Bamberger.

"Show me a fifth starter and I'll show you a losing pitcher," said Bamberger. He said it as a statement of fact.

Almost 20 years ago, he gave that advice to protege Herm Starrette, after he was named the Atlanta Braves' pitching coach and directed to find a fifth starter. In effect, Bamberger told Starrette if he was going to spend time looking for a fifth starter he better save some to look for another job.

Today, every team has five starters. Look at the major-league rosters and see how many fifth starters had winning records in 1993. And, just for the fun of it, check and see how many No. 4 starters finished over .500.

Now, ask yourself this question: If pitchers are making fewer starts, why are they being restricted to fewer pitches? Something is missing from that equation.

Before you even think this is one of those "back in the good old days," theories, perish the thought. That isn't even an issue.

Argue about quality of teams because of expansion, if that's your thing, but don't waste your time comparing the capabilities of the modern-day athlete to those of previous eras. By any standard that can be measured there simply is no comparison.

Today's athlete is bigger, stronger, faster, and, yes, more intelligent, even if we don't always want to admit it. If you don't accept that, you don't believe the streetcar is outdated.

Back to the point of the week. In Schilling's game against the Blue Jays, he allowed five hits, walked three batters and had another reach base on an error. In the process his team made three double plays, meaning Schilling faced 33 batters -- a mere six over the minimum.

In the process, Schilling averaged roughly four pitches per hitter, 16 per inning and 50 per hour (and elapsed time of a game may be the most important factor, but that's a topic for another week).

Those numbers are hardly outlandish. And the most significant factor of all is this -- in his last start of the year, Schilling was highly effective for 146 pitches. And his manager was willing to go for an extra dozen if necessary.

Bravo Curt Schilling, and one Man of the Year vote. And kudos to you too, Jim Fregosi, for trusting the quality you saw with your eyes, rather than the quantity you heard with your ears.


When neither Todd Stottlemyre nor Tommy Greene survived the third inning of that 29-runfest in Game 4, it was the earliest that both starters had departed a World Series game in 37 years.

In Game 1 of the Orioles' four-game sweep over the Dodgers in 1966, two durable pitchers lasted exactly the same amount as Stottlemyre and Greene. Dodgers right-hander Don Drysdale left after two innings in that game (as did Stottlemyre Wednesday night) and Orioles left-hander Dave McNally lasted only 2 1/3 innings (matching Greene).

There is an interesting footnote to this story. The Blue Jays (five) and the Phillies (six) each used more pitchers in Game 4 this year than the Orioles (four) did during all four games of the 1966 Series.

Hitting it on the nose

This one is as overdue as it is timely, but credit Tom Cheek, Toronto's highly respected and very astute radio play-by-play announcer, with the best analysis of the year. It came shortly after the All-Star break, when the Blue Jays were struggling to outscore every team they played.

"Maybe this is the year," Cheek observed, "that good pitching doesn't beat good hitting."

Which is why the Atlanta Braves and Chicago White Sox didn't make it beyond baseball's Final Four.

Doing it all

There's nothing like getting back to the basics, even at this time of year. Lenny Dykstra (didn't it sound like they were chanting Reg-gie, Reg-gie in the Vet?) had a big-man's performance with two homers, a double, four RBI and four runs scored in the Phillies' 15-14 loss in Game 4.

The next night, back in his leadoff-hitter mode, Dykstra opens the first inning with a walk, steals second, goes to third on a throwing error and scores what proves to be the winning run on a ground out.

Night games

You think it's easy going to the World Series two straight years? Listen to Toronto general manager Pat Gillick's description of baseball's postseason.

"It's like a 14-day endurance test -- see who can stay up until 3 a.m. 14 days in a row," said Gillick. And his team has a roof.

Ease up, umps

Major-league umpires made a mistake making an issue of CBS' "Eye In The Sky," which shows pitches as they cross the vicinity of home plate.

Whether the angle is distorted or not, it has proved rather conclusively that umpires are right much more often than players.

Writers honor Smith

At its annual World Series meeting Thursday, the Baseball Writers Association of American named the late Wendell Smith as the winner of next year's J. G. Taylor Spink award. Smith, the first black member of the BBWAA, will have a plaque dedicated in his honor in the writers' wing of the Hall Of Fame during next year's induction ceremonies.

Smith wrote for the Pittsburgh Courier and the Chicago American and, along with longtime Baltimore Afro-American sports editor Sam Lacy, he campaigned long and hard for baseball to allow blacks to play in the major leagues. He was lured away from his writing career by Branch Rickey to travel with Jackie Robinson in his first year with the Brooklyn Dodgers.


* Is it true they extended last call (until 2 a.m.) in Toronto during the World Series so the bars and SkyDome wouldn't empty at the same time?

* If Lenny Dykstra batted in the cleanup spot would he change his uniform number to 1?

* Where is Juan Samuel when the Mets need him to justify the Dykstra trade?

* How come all of the baseball people desert the World Series after the fifth game?

* Since television ratings and dollars are down and baseball takes control of the package next year, why not experiment with World Series day games on Saturday and/or Sunday afternoons?

* Does the continued absence of a commissioner and the presence of two lame-duck league presidents sound like one more attempt at collusion?

* Since his team has the top three hitters in the American League, how could Larry Hisle, as rumored, be in danger of losing his job as the Blue Jays batting coach?

6* * How many days until spring training?

Copyright © 2021, The Baltimore Sun, a Baltimore Sun Media Group publication | Place an Ad