SUBSCRIBE

Drop in immigration Israel's 'greatest shame,' opposition party says Plunging statistics major election issue

THE BALTIMORE SUN

JERUSALEM -- Jacob Glaich thought his mother was dead. In 1939, when he was 4, she left for a trip to her native Poland and was lost in the tumult of the Nazi invasion.

Fifty-two years later, the Tel Aviv businessman got a call from the Jewish Agency: His mother was alive and living in the Ukraine. She had not made contact, she explained last year after she came to live with him in Israel, because Soviet police watched Jews and threatened her when she tried to write.

"This is what Israel's about," Mr. Glaich said of his 76-year-old mother's new life as an immigrant here. "This is a place for people who have no country. This is a place where Jewish people can live free of fear."

But has Israel done enough to bring them here? The opposition Labor Party says no, and it is making that question a major issue in the national election campaign.

"This is the greatest shame in Jewish history," Shimon Peres, a former Labor prime minister, charged last week. "We could have had a million immigrants." Poor planning by the Likud government fumbled the opportunity, he said.

The allegation is commonly heard these days. Israel has seen the number of immigrants from the former Soviet Union plunge. Immigration is at its lowest levels since late 1989, just before the teetering Soviet Union allowed a surge of Jewish departures.

The Likud bloc defends its record. Friday, thousands of immigrant families sat down to their first Passover Seder in Israel. The government provided the traditional meal to many in large dining halls at mobile home camps or hotels, where they are being housed at government expense.

Nearly 400,000 immigrants have arrived since January 1990, about 90 percent of them from the former Soviet Union. The figure can be viewed two ways: It is about half the number the government had originally predicted would come, but it is a phenomenal 10 percent increase in the country's population.

"It's very complicated for a small country to absorb this many people," says Boaz Shviger, an official of the Jewish Agency, the quasi-governmental body responsible for bringing them here. "This itself is something to be proud of."

Indeed, Israel is perhaps unique in the Western world in arguing over how to bring in more people.

That goal was being stunningly fulfilled at a rate of 9,000 new immigrants each week at its peak in December 1990. But in 1992, the rate has been much lower.

Most agree the drop is chiefly due to high unemployment among immigrants, aggravated by poor housing situations and difficult social adjustments.

The evidence is on the street corners, where Russian immigrants play music, or just beg, for a few shekels.

"In Leningrad, I was a teacher, with a good apartment and a motorcycle," said David Hrishtaim, 44. He was dressed in poor but neat clothes, and he stood on Ben Yehuda street with an open briefcase singing songs for coins.

"I came here because of rising anti-Semitism. I was afraid for my little daughter," he said of his decision to emigrate nine months ago. "I have a great disappointment here. I expected it would be difficult with money. But I cannot get a job here. There are so many teachers, and I must learn Hebrew. My wife washes dishes and flats. My daughter is not happy in school.

"I think it was a mistake to come here," he said with a sad shake of his head.

An estimated one-third to one-half of the recent Soviet immigrants are unemployed. Many of the rest are underemployed -- in part-time or menial jobs. The influx is top-heavy with professionals like doctors and teachers, who can tTC only find work as porters.

The government gives immigrants a living allowance for a year. But landlords sent their rents skyrocketing, and the Russian-language papers here are full of stories of families who pay all their allowance for shoddy housing and then can barely eat.

The Labor Party argues that the government has tried a scattershot of programs that have failed to provide jobs and housing.

"This is a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity, and Likud doesn't have any clear idea about what they should be doing or shouldn't be doing," said Susan Hattis Rolef, a member of the Labor Party Central Committee.

Labor also argues that economic opportunities cannot be made without massive loans from abroad, which depend on getting loan guarantees from the United States.

Labor Party leaders say Likud has sacrificed the guarantees to keep building religious settlements in the occupied territories in defiance of Washington.

"To have more Jews is more important than to have more roofs in Judea and Samaria," Mr. Peres argued, using the biblical terms for the Israeli-occupied West Bank.

Prime Minister Yitzhak Shamir bluntly rejects that conclusion and has vowed never to stop the settlements. In an interview last week with the Jerusalem Post, he said that the drop in immigration is only temporary.

"There will always be waves," he said. "I hope we're approaching a new wave."

While there seems little public dispute with the policy of the-more-immigrants-the-better, it is uncertain if Labor's campaign on this issue will really win many votes.

"The joke is that we love immigration. We just don't love the immigrants," said one Israeli.

In a time of rising unemployment nationally, there is some resentment at the competition for jobs. Russian immigrant Michael Tsvetkov says, "Israel is better. There is no anti-Semitism here."

But Mr. Hrishtaim, the singing teacher, said Israelis snub him, and store owners yell at him to move on: "They say, 'Go back to Russia.' "

Israel has made much official ado about the newcomers, and many Israelis have taken them into their homes. But "I think already the Israelis are a little exhausted from the reception," one immigrant observed.

The immigrants themselves are an increasingly important voter group. An estimated 250,000 from the former Soviet Union will be eligible to vote in the election June 23. To Labor and Likud, traditionally closely matched, the immigrant vote is alluring.

But it is a wild card: "Just nobody knows how they will vote," one campaign worker said.

Analysts expected the immigrants to be conservative, suspicious of Labor's socialist foundations, and thus fodder for Likud gains. Opinion polls six months ago supported that theory.

But the polls have made an abrupt turnaround.

The perception that the Likud government is more interested in building settlements in the occupied territories than in helping immigrants in Israel has produced large margins for Labor. Very few immigrants live in the settlements, where there are few jobs, greater isolation and often-hostile Arab neighbors.

"We thought they were lost to anything that looked 'pink,' " said Labor's Ms. Rolef. "But they are very pragmatic. They are looking at who can do the most for them."

Some immigrants feel they are not being ardently courted by either party.

"Labor really missed the boat," said Elie Wurtman, an immigrant from America who has long been involved with the former Soviet Jews. "Had Labor held two spots [on their ticket of candidates] for Russian immigrants, they would have got lots of support. But they didn't include any. I think it was a fatal error."

The immigrants have now formed their own political party, DA -- which means "yes" in Russian. But there is no guarantee they will unite behind a separate party. And reports Friday that Nathan Sharansky, a popular prisoner of conscience from the former Soviet Union, may form a separate party could mean further splintering of the immigrant vote. But organizers of DA say they hope to elect several members to Parliament and exert influence from there.

"I don't think either Labor or Likud will do anything for us," said Yisrael Nov, a 1973 Soviet immigrant and one of the DA party's leading candidates.

"They cry at one another on television, but then they are laughing together in the coffee shop.

"Everybody talks about helping us, but nobody does," he said. "We'll have to do it ourselves."

Copyright © 2021, The Baltimore Sun, a Baltimore Sun Media Group publication | Place an Ad

You've reached your monthly free article limit.

Get Unlimited Digital Access

4 weeks for only 99¢
Subscribe Now

Cancel Anytime

Already have digital access? Log in

Log out

Print subscriber? Activate digital access