SUBSCRIBE

THE Missing Light OF Oscar Night HOWARD ASHMAN CAN'T BE WITH US, BUT HIS SONGS ALWAYS WILL BY J. WYNN ROUSUCK

THE BALTIMORE SUN

Howard Ashman put words in the mouths of an ugly beast, a beautiful girl, a little mermaid, a man-eating plant and a teapot.

Yes, a teapot. This Baltimore-born lyricist, director and producer had the magical power to animate the inanimate.

The strength of his magic will be evident tomorrow night, when "Beauty and the Beast" -- the Disney animated feature on which he served as executive producer as well as lyricist -- competes for six Academy Awards, including best picture. (The other nominations are for three original songs, score and sound.)

Although "Beauty and the Beast" is likely to win many of these, chances are it won't take the top prize. Being the first animated film ever nominated for best picture will probably be considered ample honor. Much of that honor belongs to Ashman, who died of AIDS at age 40 a little more than a year ago.

The period in which Ashman's talent was recognized by a widespread public was sadly brief: It began in 1982 with the opening of his off-Broadway smash hit, "Little Shop of Horrors," and continued through the recent release of "Beauty and the Beast." But in that short time, he conveyed a lifelong love of fairy tales to an entire nation. In less than a decade, Ashman reawakened the child in us all.

"Little Shop," based on a 1960 grade-Z Roger Corman horror movie, might not seem like your standard fairy tale, but it was to Ashman, who not only wrote the libretto, but also directed the stage show. In a 1984 interview, when the touring production played the Mechanic Theatre, he took issue with those who labeled the show "camp."

"Camp has a nasty edge," he said. " 'Little Shop' is more humanistic than that. 'Little Shop' is a fairy tale. Camp doesn't ask you to love its characters."

And Ashman did love his characters; whether they were flora, fauna or crockery, he imbued them with dignity. In "Under the Sea," his 1989 Academy Award-winning song from "The Little Mermaid," the aquatic creatures not only sing, they form a hip calypso band.

But even more than a basic respect for everything from newts to carp, a recurring theme in Ashman's work is improbable love -- the love between the nerdy assistant in a florist shop and a real babe in "Little Shop," between a mermaid and a human in "The Little Mermaid," and, of course, between a beautiful girl and a hideous beast in "Beauty and the Beast."

Underlying all of these love stories is the lesson that appearances are unimportant, and more significantly, that the unlikely is possible. On a deeper level, as Bruno Bettelheim points out in his classic analysis, "The Uses of Enchantment," the union of seemingly polar opposites is what "permits us to attain complete human fulfillment." In other words, embracing the unknown is one of the ways we grow up.

"There's something sweet and almost kind,

But he was mean and he was coarse and unrefined.

And now he's dear, and so I'm sure

I wonder why I didn't see it there before?"

"Something There" (from "Beauty and the Beast") **

And, now that "Beauty and the Beast" has become the best-selling soundtrack album in Disney history, Ashman's lovely, clear statement of these themes is virtually omnipresent on radio, in shopping malls and even on elevators.

But it would probably be a mistake to over-analyze these fairy tales. Granted, a major reason for the popularity of Ashman's work is that he chose material that strikes a common chord. But an equally significant reason is the humor and playfulness with which he approached it.

His interest in animation harks back to early childhood, when his maternal grandmother would take her grandchildren downtown to the movies on Saturdays. (These excursions must have made a strong impression because Ashman's only sibling, Sarah Gillespie, also ended up working with cartoons, as vice president and director of comic art for the United Media syndicate.)

Ashman got his first taste of theater from the Children's Theatre Association, a group with which he was active from age 7 until he graduated from Milford Mill High School in 1967. Patterns were forming in his life even then. When he was a teen-ager, the group produced a play he'd written called, "The Snow Queen," based on a story by Hans Christian Andersen, author of "The Little Mermaid."

Ashman's knack for creating speaking parts for objects and animals was almost as long-standing as his fascination with fairy tales. At Milford Mill, he co-wrote an original musical called "The Brat's Meow," loosely adapted from "Dick Whittington's Cat." "I was into anthropomorphizing even then," he recalled in 1984. "The cat was played by a strapping 6-foot-2-inch fellow."

In fact, Ashman was so adept at granting the power of speech -- and song -- to everything from cats to cactuses that when I interviewed him in New York in the heyday of "Little Shop," I half expected to hear a few words from the houseplant in the next room.

Alas, Ashman confessed, "Plants and I don't get along. I've done so much for them, and they're so ungrateful."

Fortunately, on stage and in the subsequent movie version, "Little Shop's" man-eating succulent -- dubbed Audrey II -- was anything but short on words. On the contrary, its song, "Mean Green Mother from Outer Space," written specifically for the 1986 Frank Oz movie, garnered the first Oscar nomination for Ashman and Alan Menken, composer of "Little Shop" as well as "The Little Mermaid" and "Beauty and the Beast." Audrey II is the centerpiece of "Little Shop," a reworking of the Faust legend; it is the leafy green incarnation of temptation itself.

"Would you like to be a big wheel?

Dining out for every meal?

I'm the plant can make it all real!

You gonna git it. . . .

And if you wanna be profound

And you really gotta justify

Take a breath and look around

A lot of folks deserve to die."

"Feed Me" ***

A bloodthirsty plant may seem a long way from "Beauty and the Beast's" singing-and-dancing teapot, candelabra and mantel clock. But the difference is primarily a matter of tone. Audrey II is a satirical creation; Mrs. Potts, Lumiere and Cogsworth are the last word in charm. One is a nightmare, the other a delightful daydream. Significantly, none of these things utter a word in their original sources. Animating the household objects in "Beauty and the Beast" was Ashman's idea. The best proof of its success is that it is almost impossible to imagine the movie without them. They and their songs progress the plot in the classic structural tradition of Rodgers and Hammerstein, which Ashman adhered to whether his characters had three dimensions or two.

Not all of Ashman's career was as triumphant as "Little Shop" and his work for Disney. In 1986 he collaborated with Marvin Hamlisch on a musical called "Smile," based on Michael Ritchie's 1975 movie about a beauty pageant. The show made its pre-Broadway debut at the Mechanic Theatre, then folded after six weeks on Broadway.

Although "Smile" didn't seem to truly reflect Ashman's witty sensibility, it did contain a few characteristic touches, and it received its sole Tony nomination for Ashman's book. While the show was still in rehearsal, he explained that he saw the story as a fairy tale. "It's Cinderella," he said. "It's about being crowned princess."

Furthermore, one of its songs turned out to be prescient. The big ballad was called "Disneyland" and included the lyric: "Disneyland -- I want to live in Disneyland." After "Smile," Ashman began his association with Disney, and he never returned to Broadway.

Instead, he began writing Broadway musicals for cartoons, claiming, "Animation is the last great place to do Broadway musicals." He was so good at it that last year the New York Times declared "Beauty and the Beast" "the best Broadway musical score of 1991." Moviegoers will have one more chance to hear some of Ashman's lyrics when "Aladdin," the animated feature he was working on when he died, is released by Disney next winter.

Perhaps in time Ashman would have gone back to his theatrical roots. But the truth is that more people will see his dancing teapot than will ever travel to Broadway. And frankly, the quality of "Beauty and the Beast" is so high, it'll be surprising if it doesn't have some influence on a new generation of musical theater writers. Who knows? Maybe one of them is watching the movie with his grandmother right now. After all, more than anything, Howard Ashman wrote about hope.

"Ever just the same.

Ever a surprise.

Ever as before,

Ever just as sure

As the sun will rise."

"Beauty and the Beast" **

* 1988 Walt Disney Music Co. and Wonderland Music Co. Inc.

** 1991 Walt Disney Co./Wonderland Music Co. Inc.

*** 1982 The David Geffen Company.

?3 J. Wynn Rousuck is theater critic for The Sun.

Copyright © 2021, The Baltimore Sun, a Baltimore Sun Media Group publication | Place an Ad

You've reached your monthly free article limit.

Get Unlimited Digital Access

4 weeks for only 99¢
Subscribe Now

Cancel Anytime

Already have digital access? Log in

Log out

Print subscriber? Activate digital access