SUBSCRIBE

STADIUM'S FORGOTTEN FOES A few now have tickets

THE BALTIMORE SUN

Commentators have crooned over the classic lines and traditional look of Oriole Park at Camden Yards. The national media are framing its opening as the quintessential story of spring, another quiver of rebirth for a troubled city that just won't say die.

But lost in the roar of the crowds -- literally, at times -- are the voices of the opponents, a loosely knit coalition of community crusaders, neighbors and politicians who fought a hard but losing battle several years ago against the new baseball stadium.

All still consider the stadium a mistake, but most have grown philosophical as the steel and brick have taken form in the sooty industrial neighborhood they tried to preserve. Some have made peace with the project and have bought season tickets. Others are vowing to avoid attending games there, although they admit to some temptation.

Lasting friendships were made, and political careers advanced and set back during the brief but spirited debate that cleaved the state and left some combatants bitter.

"I still think it was the wrong priority. When you've got kids hungry and people in need you don't build a stadium," said C. Lawrence Wiser, a Montgomery County Democrat who led the fight in the House of Delegates.

His efforts prompted Gov. William Donald Schaefer, a stadium proponent, to campaign for and contribute to Mr. Wiser's opponent in the next election. He lost re-election after 16 years in the House and Senate.

Now a private attorney in Kensington, Mr. Wiser said he probably will spend Opening Day at his desk, researching business contracts.

"I have no reason to step into that stadium. I'd rather go to theWalters Art Gallery," he said, acknowledging he was never a baseball fan anyway.

Objections to the stadium ranged widely. Most opposed spending the money at a time when schools were begging for books and homeless were wandering the streets. Others simply liked the storied Memorial Stadium or didn't want the extra congestion downtown. Still others resented any effort to assist wealthy team owners and their private businesses.

A pair of local attorneys founded an organization called Marylanders for Sports Sanity (MASS) shortly after the General Assembly approved the stadium project in April 1987. The group collected a near stadium-full of signatures, 44,000, on a petition to put the issue before state voters in a fall referendum.

But stadium backers said the delay would have hampered the city's bid to attract an NFL team (land has been readied for a football stadium near Oriole Park, should the league award an expansion team to Baltimore). Besides, said supporters, Baltimore had just lost the Colts in 1984 and would be relegated to minor league status if the Orioles moved.

Although the Orioles never made overt threats to move, most experts agreed that a modern stadium with money-making premium seats and deluxe concessions was the best way to compete with baseball-hungry cities trying to lure a franchise.

In September 1987, however, the Court of Appeals ruled that the legislation was not subject to referendum under Maryland's Constitution.

A Sun Poll that summer indicated that the referendum, had it been held, may have stopped Camden Yards in its tracks. With 25 percent of the respondents undecided, 39 percent said they opposed the plan, 29 percent favored it, and 7 percent said they didn't know.

"I won't say I'm bitter about it, but I think it was a very bad decision by the Court of Appeals," said Alexander J. Ogrinz III, who was vice president of MASS.

He has since moved to Charleston, W.Va., where he is a federal administrative law judge. He doesn't think he will ever attend a game at the new stadium and probably will spend Opening Day hearing a disability insurance case.

Mr. Ogrinz has fond memories of the effort, which plucked him from the obscurity of a law practice and dumped him on the local talk-show circuit. He still keeps in touch with friends met passing out petitions.

"My boys loved it. They had a stick-in-the-mud type Dad, and suddenly he was taking them to the state fair or the Bay Bridge walk to collect signatures," he said.

"I don't regret any of the effort and sacrifice. We were little guys, and we got the governor really worked up about things," he said.

A self-described libertarian Republican, Mr. Ogrinz said he was impressed by the diversity of the stadium opposition. The president of MASS, William Marker, for example, is a liberal, he said.

"Bill wanted the money for the homeless and education. I wanted it for tax reduction," Mr. Ogrinz said.

Mr. Marker, who lives a few blocks from the new stadium, was reluctant to discuss it because of his new job (he works for the state now). But he said that he has arranged to be out of town Opening Day and that he won't go to any games this year but might next season.

Sen. Howard A. Denis, a Montgomery County Republican, helped lead an unsuccessful filibuster to defeat the stadium legislation in 1987. He still opposes the project and said, "I don't expect I'll ever set foot in that place.

"It's a gigantic example of misplaced priorities," said Mr. Denis, who every year has tried but failed to stop the stadium in the Senate. This year, for example, he suggested a "windfall profits tax" to capture some of the team owner's profits should the team be sold.

The bill failed to get a hearing.

More charitable was City Councilman Wilbur E. Cunningham, a Democrat who originally captured his 3rd District seat as part of a "Save Memorial Stadium" slate. Although he says he has "real concerns about it from a public policy standpoint," he said he has purchased Orioles season tickets and hopes to attend Opening Day.

Even Sen. Julian L. Lapides, D-Baltimore, a longtime vocal opponent of the stadium, said he is looking forward to "Legislators Appreciation Night" at the team's second home game.

"It is a monument to the false gods of this nation," Senator Lapides said. "I still think it was wrong, but I think they did more than a creditable job, they did an excellent job.

"It really is a wonderful facility."

Copyright © 2021, The Baltimore Sun, a Baltimore Sun Media Group publication | Place an Ad

You've reached your monthly free article limit.

Get Unlimited Digital Access

4 weeks for only 99¢
Subscribe Now

Cancel Anytime

Already have digital access? Log in

Log out

Print subscriber? Activate digital access