The legacy of abuse is violence, child advocates warn

THE BALTIMORE SUN

Mrs. Goldberg's third-grade class, Edgewater Elementary School, 1970.

Can you pick out the kid whose father beat him with his police belt, beat his backside so badly that Jane Goldberg one day noticed he couldn't sit still at his desk? The same kid who was being sexually abused by a man, a friend of his father's?

The same kid who, by the third grade, had already suffered a nervous breakdown?

Can you pick out the kid who grew up to be a murderer?

Look at the smiling, freckle-faced boy, last row, sixth from the left. That's 9-year-old Steven Gregory Anderson.

Elaine R. Fisher, executive director of Parents Anonymous of Maryland, points to Steven Anderson's life when she argues: We should identify and treat the victims of child abuse because, if we don't, some of them will grow up to rape and kill us.

Last month, at age 31, Anderson was sentenced to life without parole for raping and murdering a 41-year-old Crofton woman. In sparing him from the gas chamber, an Anne Arundel County judge cited Anderson's miserable upbringing.

His third grade teacher, in a letter to Judge H. Chester Goudy Jr., wrote: "In all my years of teaching there are probably five children I will never forget. Steven was one of those. He never had a chance."

Ms. Fisher, whose group offers counseling to victims of child abuse and to the abusers themselves, passes out pamphlets reading, "Today's victim of child abuse is tomorrow's predator."

If you doubt her, consider the defendants in three recent capital cases:

* John Frederick Thanos, the convicted, unremorseful murderer of two Middle River teen-agers. Before a mistrial was declared in the sentencing phase of his trial, a social worker testified that Thanos was beaten, humiliated and terrorized as a child by his hard-drinking father. Thanos, who is also awaiting trial in the slaying of a Salisbury man, has spent most of his 42 years behind bars.

* Daniel E. Turner, a 33-year-old laborer sentenced last June to life without parole for the kidnapping and murder of an Army clerk who was found stabbed more than 20 times in a wooded area near Aberdeen Proving Ground. In rejecting the death penalty for Turner, the jury cited a violent childhood marked by regular beatings from his father and his mother's boyfriends. Turner's lawyer, Luther West, said his client spent most of his teen-age years in boys' homes and murdered the clerk within five months of completing a five-year prison term for assault.

* Ronald L. Scoates, who stabbed his former housemate to death during a $50 robbery at the man's home in Crownsville. At the time, Scoates was on parole for a Florida murder. The jury in the Maryland case sentenced the 31-year-old defendant to life without parole. This followed testimony that Scoates, while growing up in Florida, was abandoned by his mother and was pistol-whipped and taught to steal by his alcoholic father -- who also terrorized family members with live alligators.

Deborah Daro, research director for the National Committee for Prevention of Child Abuse, said studies show a link between abuse, juvenile delinquency and adult crime, but no causal relationship has been proved.

She noted that abused children are less likely to become lTC well-adjusted adults, but whether they become criminals can depend on personality and environmental factors beyond the family, such as growing up in areas where crime is a way of life.

To be sure, the prosecutor in Anderson's case -- and the husband of victim Gwyn Dixon Criswell -- were not overly moved by the killer's background. In unsuccessfully pushing for the death penalty, Assistant State's Attorney Cynthia M. Ferris said, "We certainly agree he had a horrible upbringing, a miserable life. But many people are abused as children and don't act out in such aggressive, negative ways."

An angry Theodore Criswell, terming Anderson's sentence "absolutely ludicrous," said the implication is, "The bigger the bum I am the more I can get away with. I bet half the people in that courtroom came from dysfunctional families. I was beaten when I was a kid. Maybe not the same manner or severity, but I was beaten."

While Ms. Daro said no scientifically valid body of research exists to definitively show how many criminals were abused as children, a number of studies have looked at the question:

* A 1985 study by the Massachusetts Department of Youth Services found that children from violent homes are nearly twice as likely to commit crimes against another person and 24 times more likely to commit sexual assaults than children who have not been abused.

* Up to a third of all homicides reveal a history of abuse in the killer's background, according to the 1986 book, "Troubled Youth, Troubled Families," by James Garbarino, president of the Chicago-based Erikson Institute for Advanced Study in Child Development.

* Ninety percent of female prisoners were sexually abused as children, says Phil Quinn, author of six books on child abuse and founder of the International Child Advocacy Resource Enterprise, Tennessee-based prevention group.

* A study by the American Association for Protecting Children shows that 80 percent of prison inmates were abused as children.

Ms. Fisher, of Parents Anonymous of Maryland, said the 80 percent figure is the lowest she's seen. She recalls going to the Maryland Penitentiary for the taping of a public-service commercial: "A guard asked me what the commercial was about, and I said it was to show that 90 percent of the inmates were abused as children. He said, 'I don't know, that sounds low to me.' He talks to them."

Look at Anderson's background, Ms. Fisher said. He was a hyperactive child, a seventh-grade dropout. A juvenile delinquent, he spent much of his teen-age years in boys' homes. He spent more than a year in a mental hospital. Drugs have been part of his life since he was a child. He began mutilating himself as a boy, burning holes in his arms with cigarettes. Later, he began swallowing things: razor blades, glass, even an antenna. Somewhere along the line he was infected with HIV. He's probably got about eight years to live.

"You walk through this person's life and look at how many red flags went up and we didn't treat it. The indications were all over the place," she said. "I'm not excusing what he did. He's a criminal. He's a murderer and he should be treated like one. But he should have been treated as a victim as a young kid. We've lost him and we've lost a completely innocent individual."

When Anderson was released from prison in 1990 -- he had been locked up for most of his 20s for burglary and other charges -- he immediately became addicted to crack cocaine, said Robert H. Waldman, an assistant public defender.

Out of prison for all of three months, Anderson set out on a Sunday morning in September 1990 to steal money to buy crack.

He ran into Mrs. Criswell, a mother of two, in the parking lot of the Crofton library. He raped her and strangled her and left her body in the woods near the library. He said he didn't know why he did it.

Mr. Waldman explained that, best as he can piece it together, a purse-snatching got out of hand because a gun gave Anderson an unaccustomed sense of "power and authority. Being in that car with a pistol in his hand, things began to take a path he never intended in the beginning. Rape is an act of domination and power, and in connection with drugs, with withdrawal or being high, he was not in his right mind," he said.

Ms. Fisher said her organization conducts support groups for abusers and the abused, goes into schools to talk to adolescents and counsels teen parents to help prevent child abuse. The organization also operates a 24-hour hot line at 243-7337.

The group's goal is to educate teachers, clergymen, judges and other professionals who deal with children and are in a position to spot signs of child abuse.

Ms. Fisher cited a 1991 study by the Child Welfare League of America. Since 1980, the study says, federal funds for child welfare services have increased 6 percent, adjusted for inflation, while reported cases of child abuse and neglect have increased 147 percent. Meanwhile, the study shows, more than a third of the states have reduced children's services to balance budgets.

Mr. Quinn, the author and child-welfare advocate, says: "Society has a responsibility to guarantee the education, protection, safety, welfare and health of its children. If society neglects to do so, then it is partly responsible for the outcome of kids who are not protected, who are not educated, who are abused or neglected. If we can ever make the home safe, we'll be taking a grand step toward making the streets safe."

Copyright © 2019, The Baltimore Sun, a Baltimore Sun Media Group publication | Place an Ad
28°