SUBSCRIBE

Md.'s recovery from recession may come slowly

THE BALTIMORE SUN

It is a well-kept secret that newspapers love to print good news, news to warm your heart, news to make you happy, news that sends you out of the house in the morning with a whistle and a bounce in your step.

The recession has made it tougher to find such news, although we did do an upbeat feature on the booming business in public auctions.

We hoped, along with Fed chairman Alan Greenspan, that lower interest rates would help revive the economy and bring a quick end to the recession. So far, however, we haven't seen much evidence of any increase in loan demand.

Neither, it appears, have the heads of some of the nation's largest corporations, about 100 of whom belong to a group named the Business Council. Meeting last weekend in Virginia, they spent considerable time disagreeing with the upbeat forecasts of their own staff economists. Although the consensus forecast is for a recovery to begin this summer, many chief executives said they simply don't see a recovery coming that soon, lower rates or not.

If lower interest rates permit banks to reduce their cost of funds and begin rebuilding balance sheets, I suppose the decline in rates will have been helpful even if it didn't do much to directly spur additional lending.

(It's certainly clear that lower rates haven't been passed along to consumers in the form of reduced charges for credit-card debts.)

And there are glimmers of a turnabout. Residential real estate markets show signs of ending their slide. Retail sales may have hit bottom. Auto sales may have hit bottom. The number of people making initial claims for unemployment insurance is getting smaller, not larger.

Still, the number of people on unemployment is not getting smaller. That's especially true when you notice that there have been actual declines in the work force. This occurs when people drop out of the labor force, which happens when they stop looking for work, which happens when they have exhausted their unemployment benefits and see no point in trying to find a nonexistent job.

In Maryland, the labor force is nearly 2 percent less than it was a year ago, and that's not because the population is shrinking. Nationally, the labor force grew by about 1.6 percent a year during the 1980s.

So, you can see that if we were forced to accommodate the normal influx of new workers into the labor force, the stated unemployment rate in Maryland could be more like 9.5 percent than the 6 percent that was reported for March.

Traditionally, Maryland has suffered less and rebounded faster than the nation when it comes to dealing with recessions. This time around, however, the upturn may be slow in coming.

The state's traditional sources of economic advantage stem from government, which is a large direct employer and also provides government contracts to private businesses, particularly in the defense industry. With government tapped out at federal, state and local levels, including declines in defense spending, Maryland's traditional edge has all but disappeared.

Looking to the private sector, at least at larger companies, doesn't provide much more encouragement. Here's a look at the first-quarter profits of 20 large corporate players in the region's economy and how they compared with the same quarter last year, which wasn't exactly a boom period in its own right. The results are in millions of dollars and the change is a percentage:

Company ... Results ... Change

BG&E; ... $41.1 ... -45

Bell Atlantic ... 353.6 ... 0

Beth. Steel ... -39.2 ... --

Black & Decker ... 4.1 ... 59

Alex. Brown ... 10.6 ... 323

Crown Central ... -5.9 ... --

CSX ... 57.0 ... -26

Giant Foods ... 39.7 ... 2

Legg Mason ... 3.8 ... 126

Manor Care ... 5.3 ... 8

Marriott ... 10.0 ... -64

Martin Marietta ... 71.0 ... 6

McCormick ... 15.2 ... 53

MNC Financial ... 154.0 ... 2,388

T. Rowe Price ... 5.6 ... -19

Ryland ... -4.4 ... --

Signet ... 6.4 ... -76

US Air ... -166.7 ... --

USF&G; ... -55.0 ... --

Westinghouse ... 98.0 ... -53

MNC Financial, owner of Maryland National and American Security banks, reported hefty income because it sold its gilt-edged credit-card operation in Delaware -- a move of weakness, not strength, that was forced on it to raise cash for debt repayments.

Alex. Brown and Legg Mason did well as the regional securities companies continued to ride out the downturn better than their battered brethren based in New York. McCormick seems to thrive in any economic climate these days.

Beyond these few, it's hard to find a source of near-term economic strength on this list.

Nationally, growth prospects for smaller companies may be better, according to a quarterly survey by the National Federation of Independent Business.

Lower interest rates have been passed on to smaller companies, which were paying an average of 11.2 percent for borrowed money last quarter, down from 11.9 percent at the end of last year.

Better still, small companies are increasingly optimistic that a turnaround is coming, and the percentage expecting to hire new employees is up sharply from earlier surveys. However, perhaps one reason tomorrow looks brighter is that the NFIB's survey found that sales declines during the first quarter were among the worst since the quarterly surveys were begun in the early 1970s.

It's impossible to know for sure how the national picture for smaller businesses might translate in Maryland. But for what it's worth, the small-business group also broke out its outlook along industry lines, which can be compared with state information.

Here are the projections for national employment gains among small businesses by industry, expressed in terms of what percentage of the companies feel that their employment will increase in the current quarter.

They are aligned with the percentage of Maryland employment in each industry, to provide some idea of what would happen here if things did turn up as forecast. In Maryland, 20 percent of the state's 2.13 million employment is in government; the percentages here relate to the state's non-government employment, which totals about 1.7 million people.

(The breakout between services and professional employment is not clear in Maryland's job statistics, so these categories were lumped together at the state level, where they generate 36 percent of private-sector employment.)

Industry ... Increase ... Md %

Construction ... 33 ... 9

Manufacturing ... 28 ... 12

Transportation ... 27 ... 6

Wholesale trade ... 21 ... 6

Retail trade ... 17 ... 24

Finance ... 10 ... 8

Services ... 22 ... *

Professional ... 19 ... 36

Unfortunately, the brightest prospects for smaller companies are areas with relatively small concentrations in Maryland, while 60 percent of the state's employment (retail trade and services) is in areas with more modest growth forecasts.

This has not been a terribly nasty recession by even recent historical standards. But the idea that it can somehow be painlessly put behind us after only several months appears less and less realistic.

To advocates of an electoral economic cycle, such as cynics like me, a weak 1991 is not particularly surprising or alarming. The best timing for a recovery, from the Republicans' standpoint, would be in the spring of next year, supporting a strong re-election effort by President Bush.

If the recovery doesn't appear cooperative to this extended timetable, the White House might feel the need to help matters. We'd then get some artificial economic stimulation and, if history is a guide, some bad economics as well.

Copyright © 2021, The Baltimore Sun, a Baltimore Sun Media Group publication | Place an Ad

You've reached your monthly free article limit.

Get Unlimited Digital Access

4 weeks for only 99¢
Subscribe Now

Cancel Anytime

Already have digital access? Log in

Log out

Print subscriber? Activate digital access