The difference is more than semanticRay Jenkins,...


The difference is more than semantic

Ray Jenkins, in his column in The Sun on Feb. 3 entitled PPrecision Devices vs. Weapons of Terror," is guilty of the same criminalization of the language for which he excoriates the U.S. armed forces. Clearly military expertise is no requirement for sensible war commentary. But before the writer begins to equate American and Iraqi military tactics and ethics in the gulf war, he must familiarize himself with the history of warfare and with the way modern weapons work.

Jenkins' main thesis is that the language of war is nonsensical. I don't agree. Soldiers speak differently than we do simply because they live vastly different lives than we do. I see nothing nonsensical about the term "air sortie," and certainly I know no one who views a sortie as a lovely Sunday stroll in the park. If Jenkins had bothered to look up the word in even an old dictionary, he would have seen that "sortie" has been an accepted English word ever since aviation began to play a military role.

When he declared that we undertook bombing raids in which 18,000 tons of TNT were dropped from planes for 10 hours, he really missed the mark. I calculate that 18,000 tons of bombs were not achieved in 10 hours but more like two weeks.

Suddenly the 18,000 tons become equivalent to the Hiroshima bomb. This comparison disturbs me. If the first 10 hours in the gulf was equivalent to the Hiroshima bomb, I would also expect Jenkins to state that with this equivalence is a slightly different death toll: 91 in Iraq (if the Iraqis are to be believed) as opposed to 78,000 in Hiroshima.

I was irritated by the argument equating Iraq's potential use of biological weapons with the possible spread of typhus due to the destruction of the water system of Baghdad by Allied aircraft. These two possibilities can simply not be compared meaningfully. The use of biological weapons is a specific military tactic. Even if one assumes that the spread of typhus among Iraqis due to the disruption of Baghdad's water supply is a possibility, this would be an indirect and clearly unintended result of our air attacks not a purposeful strategy.

I was also annoyed by the characterization of President Bush's "good vs. evil" statement as language abuse. If Jenkins wants to quibble over the words good and evil, fine; but if he refuses to see the distinction between bacteriologic weapons, terrorism and Scud missiles as opposed to our attempt to destroy Iraq's capability to undertake these tactics, he is misinformed. If that logic had been used during World War II, one might have equated the Malmedy massacre and concentration camps with our destruction of Germany's hydroelectric dams in order to cripple Nazi war production. During World War II, we liberated countries with medieval monarchies (as Jenkins derisively categorizes Kuwait) to save them from a man who was far worse.

Joseph M. Balkoski


Nader's bill

I was amused by the report from the Ralph Nader Public Citizen consumer group (Evening Sun, Feb. 6), which claims that the cost of the Persian Gulf war effort will be $268 billion.

I was in medical school in the early 1970s when Mr. Nader came to Tennessee to help defeat the attempt to build a breeder nuclear reactor in that state. He said at that time that we did not need to build nuclear reactors to meet our country's energy needs. I can still see clearly see him saying, in that voice of self-assurance, that the way to meet these needs was to ". . . keep importing cheap foreign oil." Now, the bill for this oil is coming due, and it's much, much higher than Mr. Nader told us it would be.

Joel Hammer


War of empire

As the bombs burst in air in the Persian Gulf, the violence of the U.S. empire can no longer be concealed by covert CIA operations or channeled through foreign mercenaries. Training contras and death squads, testing nuclear weapons and exercising war-game skills cannot satisfy for long. We need a war to justify and maintain our huge military machine and keep the defense industry rolling in wealth. We need a war to unify our violence-addicted culture. We need a war to remind the world who's in charge. Japan and Germany may have surpassed us economically, but they need the U.S. to be their bodyguard.

The empire needed an enemy to hate and subjugate now that the Soviet Union's power has subsided. We could not have created a better enemy than Saddam Hussein. Since empires don't smile upon invasions, he should not have invaded Panama -- oops, I mean Nicaragua oops, pardon me, Kuwait.

A day of prayer was called for by President Bush. Yes, we need a day -- many, many days to confess and repent of the violence within our nation, violence now being exported because of our need to dominate and control under the pretense of creating or maintaining democracy. How democratic is this bloody war?

John D. Oliver

The writer is a Baltimore minister.

A liberator?

I find it ironic that the Palestinians of the West Bank and Gaza are supporting Saddam Hussein and even calling for more missile strikes against Israel, but at the same time they are demanding that Israel provide each Palestinian with a free gas mask.

Two years ago, with much fanfare, the PLO recognized Israel and envisioned the co-existence of two states, Israel and Palestine, west of the Jordan. If the Palestinians really meant what they said then, they would cooperate with Israel now that the whole region is in immediate danger.

Several Palestinians interviewed on television have expressed their hope that Saddam will liberate their country. However, the Arabs' military attempts to liberate Palestine (and destroy the Jews) in 1948, 1967 and 1973 are precisely what caused the Palestinian refugee problem in the first place. I shudder to imagine what kind of "liberator" Saddam would be.

Jeffrey P. Jarosz


Unfair criticism

Once again nursing homes are the topic of unfair and hard criticism. Good for Bert Breuer, a paraplegic, who wrote about his successful escape from a nursing home (Other Voices, Jan. 29). It's great he is on his own in his own apartment and has had the determination to accomplish this.

However, his sharp criticism of his time spent in nursing homes is not justified. I would guess Mr. Breuer would certainly not be physically or mentally able to be where he is now had it not been for the care and, yes, discipline he received in nursing homes.

I attribute my beliefs to 14 years as a care-giver in a Baltimore County nursing home. I am pleased, as are all of us in the home, when a resident can adjust to making it in the outside world. At the same time, I know we do our jobs so well, we are the ones who make it possible.

Rosemary Goodman

The writer is activities director at the Riverview Nursing Centre in Essex.

Really, now

How serious can we take an expert economist who, in order to reach his deficit number of $186 billion for the 1992 fiscal year which starts Oct. 1, counts the Social Security surplus, excludes the banks' bailout cost and does not even mention the war costs in 1991?

David Chupnick



At a time when the state economy is in chaos and public employees are forced to share a disproportionate burden to balance the state budget, it is ironic that The Evening Sun would print a scurrilous article like "This one's for you" (Jan. 28).

The article reached a new low in repeating a joke about state employees published in the "State House Swirl" column. What state employees and other public employees need right now is an occasional pat on the back, not a continual kick in the seat of the pants.

To think that someone in the governor's office implied that state employees are "uninspired" or "downright lazy" is to add insult to injury. We are already facing an increased work week without additional compensation, an increase in medical insurance premium costs, denial of a cost-of-living pay raise, denial of incremental step salary increases and the possibility of massive layoffs at any moment.

I take issue with the person in the governor's office who made these remarks and am disappointed in The Evening Sun for printing something so detrimental to the morale of all public employees in the state.

Joel Dan Lehman

The writer is president of Maryland Classified Employees Association. Governor Schaefer has restored the 35 1/2 -hour work week for state employees.

Mozart degraded

PBS' recent production of Mozart's "Don Giovanni" was one of smut, degradation and outrage. If only Mozart could see "what they did to his song!" His cadaver would have post-mortem spasms.

I have never seen Donna Anna's famous aria staged with her ramming a heroin syringe into her arm. If this is education, a means to entice the population to love opera -- forget it!

This production was more of a farce and ridicule of opera itself. Where does cheapness end?

Grier Taylor


Signs of times?

If our governor ever gets his hoped-for nomination for the presidency, the voters of the nation should be warned of a possible deluge of plaques announcing that projects are "brought to you by President William Donald Schaefer and the people of the United States of America."

Lem Hall


Copyright © 2021, The Baltimore Sun, a Baltimore Sun Media Group publication | Place an Ad