The Aegis
Harford County

Harford school board hears challenges facing recruitment and retention

Despite all the public posturing over the past several years about teacher pay increases, Harford County Public Schools has one of the highest teacher retention rates in the state, according to a recently release report on teacher recruitment and retention.

But school officials continue to warn Harford's system faces challenges in recruiting and retaining teachers and other staff members as pay rates fall behind neighboring counties and the cost of benefits increases. And, the report notes, two of the counties with higher retention rates are on Harford's borders.


"Our competitive position and base pay has eroded as neighboring school systems have provided structure and step adjustments when we have not been able to do so," Jean Mantegna, assistant superintendent for human resources, told members of the Board of Education, as she and Howard Kutcher, senior manager of Human Resources, presented a report on recruitment and retention during the board's Dec. 16 meeting.

The report covers a 12-month period ending Sept. 30, 2013.


"Although HCPS offers a very generous and attractive benefits package, our base hiring rate for teachers is below that of our immediate neighbors, and [base pay is] $5,892 less than the highest base rate offered within the state at a school system less than a 30-minute drive from Bel Air," Mantegna continued.

She also noted that compensation for experienced teachers "has fallen sharply," with a 15-year Harford County teacher earning $4,500 less per year than his or her counterpart in Baltimore County and $7,900 less than in Cecil County.

Mantegna highlighted the state's Fair Share Act, passed by the General Assembly and signed into law by Gov. Martin O'Malley during the spring of 2013. School employees who are not members of a union but still have the benefits obtained by that union must pay a "fair share" fee, essentially union dues even though they are not union members. The Maryland State Teachers Association, the statewide union, has lobbied for years to get this requirement, known as agency shop.

"The potential for future employee fees associated with recent fair share legislation could result in reductions in the take-home pay of more than 50 percent of our system-wide workforce that are not presently dues-paying union members," Mantegna explained.

The school system currently has a 92.6 percent overall teacher retention rate, however, according to statistics presented by Mantegna. Harford employees approximately 2,900 classroom teachers.

That retention rate places Harford at fourth best in the state, after Frederick (95 percent), Cecil, (93.5 percent) and Baltimore County, (93.1 percent).

"Overall turnover has remained relatively flat, even in light of our declining competitiveness in salary," Mantegna explained.

She said retirements were the No. 1 reason for staff turnover; retirements accounted for almost 25 percent of all staff separations during the 12-month reporting period.


Harford teachers salaries have been flat the past several years. A 1 percent cost of living increase was granted in 2012, and in some years the school system did not fund either cost of living adjustments or step increment raises tied to longevity and professional performance, blaming the county government for not providing enough money for them.


Harford County Public Schools also continues to hire for teaching and non-teaching positions, despite cuts in positions to reconcile the budget for the current fiscal year, Mantegna told board members.

School system officials cut 115 positions in the schools and central office, including 46 that were filled, as part of the budget reconciliation passed in June.

Mantegna said "all but three" of those 46 were hired back.

"Even though a number of vacant positions were removed from the budget this past year, HCPS hired 414 replacement staff members, roughly 25 percent higher than the same period in the previous year," Mantegna said.


Teacher hires were 6 percent lower than the previous year.

She said the school system handled 2,414 applications for teaching positions during the past year, or an average of 15 applications for each of the 164 positions filled.

School officials still face the challenge of finding teachers who specialize in science, technology, engineering and math subjects, as well as special education, library and media science, family and consumer science and speech-language pathologists, or speech therapists, she said.

Mantegna noted officials are working to increase diversity among HCPS employees; she said 13.1 percent of newly-hired staffers identify as being part of a minority group, and recruiters are working to expand their outreach and develop stronger relationships with Historically Black Colleges and Universities.

School board member James Thornton encouraged Mantegna to provide breakdowns by school in terms of showing data on staff departures, and encouraged the school system to pursue greater employee diversity.

"I think it's important for this district to reflect, in the classroom, the demographics of our student body," he said.



School board members unanimously approved the promotion of Havre de Grace Elementary School Principal Renee Villareal to coordinator of school improvement and intervention, serving the entire school system.

Mantegna said the coordinator "provides instructional and administrative leadership for the coordination, development, implementation and evaluation of the school system's school improvement plans and initiatives, and alternative learning and other intervention programs."

Recognitions/sportsmanship awards

School board members recognized the C. Milton Wright High School field hockey team for its state 3A championship win this fall.

"This, by far, has been the most memorable season for each and every one of us," Sabrina Rhodes, one of three team captains, told the audience. "Thank you again for all your support; we are very grateful."

The Aegis: Top stories

The Aegis: Top stories


Daily highlights from Harford County's number one source for local news.

Interim Superintendent Barbara Canavan, who said she remembered some of the players' faces from her time as principal of Southampton Middle School, congratulated the field hockey team.

"Congratulations and thanks for just all of the accolades that you brought to Harford County Public schools," she said. "Enjoy the holidays."

Teams from multiple schools also won sportsmanship awards in the Susquehanna and Chesapeake Divisions of the Upper Chesapeake Bay Athletic Conference.

Finally, faculty members were presented with various awards, including the 2013-14 Maryland Association for Health, Physical Education, Recreation and Dance Emerging Leaders Award, which went to Brian Harris of North Harford Middle School and Allison Hunsinger of Red Pump Elementary School.

The winners of the 2013014 Simon McNeely Award were physical education instructors Matthew Roseland of Patterson Mill Middle School and Ronald Stump of Roye-Williams Elementary School.

Ginny Popiolek won the American Alliance for Health, Physical Education, Recreation and Dance R. Tait McKenzie Award.


George Toepfer won the Maryland Council for Social Studies Instructional Leader of the Year award.