Why Big Show should win: Rarely does a heel back up his boasts, if the Big Show loses yet another WrestleMania match, it looks like he's not a big game player. As it were, Big Show rarely loses clean unless its to a main eventer and Cody Rhodes isn't quite there yet.
Why Cody Rhodes should win: In his promos, Rhodes has done a nice job of putting over that Big Show is a nearly unstoppable force the other 364 (or in 2012, 365) days a year, but at WrestleMania, he's a choke artist. That's practically a built-in excuse for Show to lose here. More than anything, Rhodes is clearly a star on the rise and his Intercontinental Championship reign is one of the longest in the modern era. Last year, he used a WrestleMania victory over Rey Mysterio as a launching pad. Defeating the Big Show and making good on his claims could elevate him straight to the main event.