Word of the attack and the subsequent arrests of the boys madeevening newscasts and morning newspapers, and fueled more local anxiety. In a city besieged by violence, it seemed to show that no one, not even an octogenarian city official, was safe.
What's less well known is this: Instead of seeking vengeance, Spector quietly decided to become the boys' advocate.
She and a team of nonprofit workers, mentors, cooks and coaches, a group Spector has dubbed the "Good Samaritans," have been working with the boys for months — during and after their time on house arrest — and say their grades, school attendance and attitude have shown marked improvements.
Though the boys are still works in progress, their supporters say, the teens are now emerging as leaders in the neighborhood, trying to teach others to stay out of trouble.
Last month, around the one-year anniversary of the December 2016 attack, Spector joined the older teen in front of a large audience at her Park Heights synagogue, where leaders from across the city presented him with an award for his progress.
The boy who had once punched Spector in the face now shyly tried to hide behind her from the view of the crowd.
"He was so overwhelmed, if he didn't hold on to me, he was going to collapse," Spector said.
"I felt scared on the inside," the teenager said. "It was a lot of people and I thought they were going to be ashamed of my actions. But a lot of people started shaking my hand and said they were proud of me."
A week later, Spector presented another award to the younger boy, who hugged her, called her "ma'am" and said, "I messed up."
The Baltimore Sun is not identifying either teen because they were charged as juveniles.
The relationship likely would never have developed if not for UEmpower of Maryland. The nonprofit provides a range of services, including teaching youths how to become chefs.
Rikki has been very benevolent, very caring
Baltimore Mayor Catherine Pugh
Share quote & link
Shortly after the carjacking, Spector attended a court hearing for the boys.
Michelle Suazo, UEmpower's cofounder and vice president, pulled Spector aside and talked to her about the boys' situation. Despite the crime, Suazo told Spector, she believed the boys had a lot of promise.
"We invited her to come to the neighborhood and see how much is needed here," Suazo said. "We had kept on saying we need something here. We need something. And nobody was listening."
The median household income in their Carrollton Ridge neighborhood is less than $25,000. Nearly half of families live below the poverty line. Lead paint violations are more than three times the city average, and youths are nearly twice as likely to be murdered as elsewhere in Baltimore. The younger boy lived in a home where the electricity had been shut off, and seldom attended school.
"We went to court not to say they shouldn't be punished, but to see if there was some way we could find a solution," Suazo says. "They need to stay busy. They need to stay engaged. Our goal was to be louder than the streets. If you're not there every day the streets just call the kids in at a very early age."
It would have been easy for Spector to stay angry at the teens. She could have asked the judges to jail them for years.
Spector says she drew on her Jewish faith, and chose to forgive them.
"The Talmud says you first have to have empathy," she said. "You have to do acts of love and kindness."
That day in court, Spector — sporting a big swollen black eye — approached the older boy and started talking. She told him, "Kids don't hit grown-ups."
"He burst out crying, and he hugged me," Spector says. "That was in the courtroom. I knew I was hooked. I was going to be there."
The boy recalls being overcome with emotion.
"We spoke. We hugged," he recalls. "She gave me a kiss on my cheek. It made me feel happy. I started feeling sad for what we did to her."
"I was so sad, what we did to her, especially when I seen her face," he said. "I was like we couldn't have done this. Not this bad. But it turns out we did. It just broke my heart. Every time she seen me, she kept giving me kisses on my cheek. I kept giving her big hugs."
Suazo asked the older teen: "What is it that I can do for you? He said, 'Miss Michelle I want a job.'
Since then, she says, "I've been non-stop trying to find a solution. He is going to be my partner in this effort to bring good things to the neighborhood."
The boys were placed underhouse arrest, meaning they had to wear monitoring devices and couldn't leave the house without permission. The younger teen spent two months in a juvenile rehabilitation facility in Montgomery County. They are required to continue to report to the Department of Juvenile Services for supervision and drug testing.
Suazo wanted to make sure they were engaged in positive activities during their house arrest. She intervened with the courts to make sure they could attend catering and cooking jobs with UEmpower.She lined up a tutor for the younger boy who was no longer enrolled in school.
"I asked the judge if they could participate in the cooking and he said yes," she said.
So at one event, the teens made food for Spector.
"I didn't think she was going to take it," the older boy said."When she tasted it, I felt good in myself."
City Councilwoman Rikki Spector speaks about being assaulted by teens who attempted to steal her car. (Baltimore Sun video)
All the while, he was trying to do better.
"After this incident happened, and they put me on house arrest," he said, "I just started busting my school work out. My grades started going up and up and up. I don't hang around the people I was doing that dumb stuff with. I hang around with whole new people who don't even live on this side of town. So my life, it just turned around."
One day while on a catering job, Suazo noticed some of the boys' old friends hanging out on a corner.
"I thought, 'Wow, he chose to go to the catering job with us,'" she said. She said she later learned one of the youths on the corner was shot and killed. "I just think about that every day. Every choice is a life or death choice."
UEmpower has helped organize a team of workers who are bringing services — including food and mentoring — toSouthwest Baltimore. They worked out of other locations in the past, but are setting up shop at the Samuel F.B. Morse recreation center, which they fought to keep open.
Melvin Willingham, founder of the Makings of a Man mentorship program, mentors the boys and other youths in the neighborhood.
Robert Stewart, "Chef Stew" of the Transition Kitchen, provides culinary training and creates catering jobs.
Coach Derwin Hannah runs youth football, basketball and baseball teams in the neighborhood.
Donor Rosanne Skirble created a healthy snack company called SeedyNutty that she is giving to the youths for an entrepreneurship opportunity. UEmpower is seeking $24,000 to get the company up and running in what is now a food desert.
While not in a leadership role with thenonprofit, Spector helped the organization get access to the rec center and adjacent school. She regularly attends the group's functions.
On a recent Wednesday night, Willingham spoke to a group of youths about visualizing their future, setting goals and taking the steps needed to achieve them.
"We need to look in the mirror and define ourselves with what? Integrity," Willingham said. "We need to define ourselves with integrity."
Hannah, the football coach, said he visited the teens after he learned of the attack.
"They've changed," he said. "It still takes a lot of work, but we're still holding fast and hoping for the best."
Suazo says the rec center now functions as a sort of ground zero for the range of services UEmpower provides. Next month,she hopes to open a kitchen at the school as a permanent site to feed people in the neighborhood.
"This is a safe zone. If you take this away, there's nothing," she says.
She says the boys are constantly reminded of the dangers of the streets. One summer day while walking to a cookout, youths passed the body of a young man who'd been shot to death.
The mother of the older boy in the carjacking says she's noticed a large improvement.
"He's more focused on what he wants to do in life. He's trying to finish school and he's trying to be a role model for kids in the neighborhood, but also his little brothers," Lakeisha Jones said. "He helps more around the house.
"I've seen a whole 360 on him. He was rebelling but he came back. That's the change I've seen. I've seen growth. … He talks about Ms. Spector a lot. He appreciates her. He was really sorry."
She said she thinks the arrest helped scare him straight.
"He was actually very scared. He was terrified. He said he won't ever go back. He said, 'This is not where I'm supposed to be.'"
Mayor Catherine Pugh was at the synagogue to present the award to the boys.
"Rikki has been very benevolent, very caring," she said. "Taking these young men under her arms and mentoring them to a better lifestyle. Their families are grateful. I know they are. I think they are feeling they've had a second chance and that's what she's given them."
The older boy says he's most attracted to the cooking skills he's learning from UEmpower. He said he believes it's a way for kids in the neighborhood to stay busy.
"It will get younger and older kids out of trouble. It will keep us away from the streets. And it will keep us from doing bad stuff in the streets. Instead of us being outside, we'll be in here," he said.
He says he doesn't feel safe in his neighborhood.
"I've got to watch my back in the streets, because I don't know what people are trying to do to me," he said. He says he tries to spend time in other parts of the city. "I don't like being scared. Why should I be scared of where I'm from?"
The most important lesson he learned is to be careful about the people you surround yourself with.
"I'm trying to teach [younger kids] not to hang around people they know are going to do bad stuff and to choose the right people to hang around. When it's time to leave and when it's time to stay."
When he attacked Spector, he said, "I wasn't thinking. I was trying to be a cool kid and do the stuff they do. And not thinking about my actions. Trying to be along with the team."
He sees a future for himself. He'd like to make it as a pro athlete — he's known for a strong throwing arm in football — but if that doesn't work out, he thinks he will become a veterinarian. He collects fish, turtles, iguanas, snakes and bearded dragons.
Spector "gave me a chance," he said. "I took that chance as an advantage and did what I had to do in school, outside of school, and stayed away from trouble. Period."
Breaking News Alerts Newsletter
As it happens
Get updates on the coronavirus pandemic and other news as it happens with our free breaking news email alerts.
Suazo says Spector has become an important advocate for the boys.
"She's tiny but she's powerful," she said. "She has so much energy. Now the boys have a huge advocate in their corner with Rikki. She wants to see them succeed as much as we all do."
Spector says she's dedicating the rest of her life to reforming the juvenile justice system.
"They're our children," she said. "They walk where we walk. If they're going to do bad, they're going to be doing bad where we are. I'm going to spend my next 40 years fixing the juvenile justice system."