Dear Amy: My child came out to my husband and me as non-binary, using “they/them pronouns and a new name.
I am struggling to change the way I address them, but I am honestly trying.
My husband is not.
My husband flat-out told them that he doesn’t care if they identified differently; he will continue to use their birth name and pronouns.
My husband says he doesn’t care what other people call them, and that there is no negative connotation meant on his part, but I know it is and will be taken that way.
I told him that my child may refuse to interact with him if he refuses to address them in this new way, but he says he doesn’t care.
His partial acceptance confuses me on what to do.
Based on previous discussions, I believe my child will keep in touch with me, but not my husband, but I always said I would leave my husband if he showed hate to a child of mine.
This situation is confusing, because this isn’t rejection – it’s just not really acceptance.
Should I leave him?
Dear Torn: I’m going to dodge the direct question regarding whether you should leave your husband – because it is too binary. And marriage – like gender and sexuality – occurs across a spectrum.
However, you say that he is not rejecting your child, but is just not accepting them. You see his response as a “partial” acceptance.
I see it differently. When someone says, “This is who I am. This is my name. This is my identity…” and another person responds: “No, it isn’t…” that’s basically the definition of “rejection.”
Many people in your (also my) generation would freely admit to struggling adjusting to non-binary gender and “they/them” pronouns. I think it’s natural to be thrown off when a child who you have raised with one identity announces such a change.
But accepting someone’s right to define their own personhood and identity is what it means to love someone. So, while addressing your child differently might be hard at first, accepting them should be easy.
Your reaction: “I’m struggling, but I’m working on it,” is an authentic statement, recognizing your child’s — and your — humanity.
Your child’s identity is not hurting anyone. Your husband’s response is.
Should you leave him? I don’t know. Maybe he needs more time to accept what is actually a very simple human right – the right to self-determination.
But is his response hateful? I believe it is.
Dear Amy: Recently a very good friend of over 20 years took an overnight road trip with me.
We have been through everything together – his breakups, the death of my husband, travels, you name it.
After this last trip, he refused to return my calls or texts.
Finally, he texted me and said, “I am having a hard time getting over this last trip. I wanted to call you, but I knew I would be too emotional to discuss it. I’m sure you don’t remember what you did, but I can’t forget.”
Amy, I was dumbfounded! I immediately texted him, apologizing for whatever it was, asking him to please let me know what I did to upset him.
I did this numerous times with no response, until he texted back: “Soon, I’ll let you know.”
I racked my brain, and even called the hotel we stayed at to ask if there were any complaints about our stay.
At this point I want to text him and say, “You are a lucky, lucky man to have so many close friends that you can afford to toss one away with no explanation.” What do I do?
– Scratching My Head in CA
Dear Scratching: Your pal texted: “I’m sure you don’t remember what you did…”
So, he knows you don’t remember what you did to offend him, but he also won’t fill you in.
His behavior has effectively made you the wounded party, now, and I agree with your current sentiment toward him.
I do wish you two would be brave enough to at least hash this out verbally, however, versus trading cryptic texts.
Dear Amy: “Heartbroken at 63” was written by a woman whose older husband has been involved with a 19-year-old for two years.
That needs to be investigated. He might have started with a minor!
Something about this is fishy!
Dear Herberdenia: I agree that this relationship is “fishy” – “catfishy,” in my opinion, as this “relationship” seemed to be occurring online.
Got a question for Amy? Enter it here and we’ll send it to her.
Sign up here to receive the Ask Amy newsletter to get advice e-mailed to your inbox every morning, and for a limited time — get the book "Ask Amy: Essential Wisdom from America’s Favorite Advice Columnist" for $5.
©2021 Amy Dickinson.