Marie flashes back to when she cut her deal with Papa Legba and gave him her newborn daughter. Fiona asks Marie to introduce her to The Papa. Marie says if she wants it badly enough, The Papa will pay her a visit.
Misty and Madison are marching along with a funeral procession on the streets of New Orleans, sharing kabobs. I've taken some heat, privately, for some of my commentary on the fashion choices that the ladies of this show have made, but that won't stop me from praising Madison's turban and Misty's top hat in this scene. Say what you will about Emma Roberts as an actress, but her headwear this season has been impeccable.
Madison tries to put it in Misty's head that Fiona and Stevie might not have had Misty's happiness in mind when Stevie paid her a visit. "Are you saying Stevie was working me?" Misty asks. I love it when she speaks carny. Madison takes Misty to a cemetery in an attempt to convince her that she is every bit as powerful. Madison casually raises a man from the dead and convinces Misty that she has some serious abilities.
Madison tries convincing Misty to be her own woman and drop Stevie's shawl into a casket, but her tactics are all just misdirection. When Misty turns her back, Madison knocks her out, locks her in a casket, and orders some gravediggers to seal her in a mausoleum. Madison does the Stevie twirl with the shawl to celebrate her victory.
Zoe accompanies Nan to the hospital to visit Luke, where they learn that Luke passed away the day before. They pay Luke's mom a visit, where they learn that she had him cremated. Nan is furious, of course, because this means she can't resurrect her love. Nan uses her abilities to force Luke's mom to drink bleach, to pay for murdering her son.
After her mother cast her aside for bringing Hank into their lives, Cordelia visits with Myrtle, in search of a pep talk and a renewed sense of purpose. Myrtle is too wrapped up in being fabulous to bring much in the way of encouragement, though. "Your salad dressing is magical! Maybe you could bottle it," Myrtle offers, but this is not what Cordelia wanted to hear. Cordelia rages, smashing up her greenhouse.
Fiona conjures The Papa and gives him a cocaine offering, trying to earn his favor. They discuss the terms of a potential immortality contract. Fiona offers to do whatever it takes to make it happen, even crippling her daughter or murdering an innocent, once a year. "Then, we have a deal," The Papa says. Fiona asks him to seal the deal with a kiss, but when they lock lips, The Papa calls the deal off. "You have nothing to sell," he says. "You have no soul."
The Axeman appears and tells Fiona that since the deal with Papa Legba is off, they simply need to determine who the next supreme is and kill her. "I have no soul," Fiona says. "I'll just kill them all."
The next day, Nan hears Marie's kidnapped baby crying and confronts her about it. "I just killed the woman next door with my powers, and I will kill you," Nan says when Marie threatens her. Nan wants to take the baby back, but Fiona intervenes and orders her away.
Marie tells Fiona that the baby is for The Papa, and that she will learn just how gruesome his annual requests are. "No, we couldn't come to terms," Fiona tells her. Marie tells Fiona that she regrets giving up her own daughter and that this child reminds her of her own, but that The Papa needs an innocent soul. Fiona sees this as an opportunity to kill two birds with one stone, so the two of them drown Nan in the bathtub.
This doesn't exactly fit Papa's criteria of an innocent soul, however. Fiona maintains that despite the fact that Nan killed one of their neighbors, she was mostly innocent, because the woman had it coming. "Oh, come on, be a sport," Marie begs him when he comes to collect. Papa relents and takes Nan back to the other side with him.
"Perfect ending to a long day," Fiona says to Stevie Nicks, and the episode ends as Stevie serenades her.