The New York Times Ben Brantley calls Tiffany's "Menagerie" the "most revealing revival of a cornerstone classic for many a year to come." He adds that Quinto and Jones give "career-defining performances," and the cast has honed an "emotional sharpness" beyond their "fine" performances in Cambridge.
Elysa Gardner of USA Today gives high marks to Jones in this "magnificent and harrowing" new revival that will "leave a glow in your heart." She writes that Jones' turn as Amanda will "amaze even her most ardent admirers in its depth and compassion."
Joe Dziemianowicz of the New York Daily News writes that "Menagerie" should break your heart, and this "striking" revival "cracks it wide open." He adds that the Bob Crowley's "strong, spare scenery" match the "lean and natural" performances.
David Rooney of the Hollywood Reporter writes the "transfixing" production taps into the intimacy of the nearly 70-year-old play "in ways that give the impression you're seeing it for the first time."