The new space at 3700 Toone St. will offer more parking and better plumbing and electrical features to handle the shop’s business, says DiPasquale. The storefront was previously occupied by Ceriello Fine Foods, a New York-based Italian chain. At least 60 seats indoor will be complemented by an undetermined amount of outdoor seating.
Still, DiPasquale said, leaving Highlandtown, a neighborhood where he was born and raised, is “a little bittersweet. We like it here.” Many families in the area have been shopping there for generations. “They’re upset, they’re sad. [Some customers] felt like one of the reasons they moved here was we were here.”
The shop owner said he plans to offer shuttle service and delivery for Highlandtown customers. He does not intend to raise prices at the new place.
The business has been a stalwart for Italian deli fans, and a reminder of the marketplaces that once populated much of downtown Baltimore.
In 2007, Guy Fieri featured it on “Diners, Drive-Ins and Dives.” Two years later, its crab cakes made it to Maryland Public Television’s “Eatin Crabcakes: The Best I Ever Had.”
Breaking News Alerts Newsletter
As it happens
Get updates on the coronavirus pandemic and other news as it happens with our free breaking news email alerts.
A second store, in Harborview, opened in 2017. The company also owns Mastellone’s, on Harford Road.
While the recent coronavirus crisis has hurt many food service businesses, DiPasquale said his family business has fared just fine. An increase in carryout and market orders has compensated for the loss of catering revenue, which usually makes up 30% of its income. Many customers have made special trips to Highlandtown to pick up orders, wanting to ensure their favorite spot stays afloat.
“Our food travels well,” DiPasquale said. “It’s fun food.”
The Gough Street building was not DiPasquale’s first location in Baltimore: It started one block away.
DiPasquale’s grandfather, Luigi DiPasquale, opened the Italian grocery in 1914 on Claremont Street in a then-German neighborhood. The move to its current building in 1988 was also controversial among change-averse customers, who’d grown accustomed to the ambience of the first location. “People were thrown off by it,” DiPasquale said.