I'm a gay guy in an open relationship and I'm on Recon, a gay hookup/dating site for guys into leather/fetish/BDSM. My partner, who isn't kinky, knows I have a profile there and it's not a problem. Today I got a message from a new guy, and when we exchanged face pics, I saw that he looks exactly like "Peter," my boyfriend's best friend's fiancé! I asked him if that was him, and he stopped responding. What should I do? My BF doesn't want to know much about my extracurricular activities, but this could make our next double date extremely awkward. We see this other couple a fair amount, and even though I think this guy is good-looking, I would never sleep with him because of the social situation. On the other hand, if I'm wrong and they're not the same person, bringing it up with them could make things awkward, especially since I'm pretty secretive about my kinks and have zero desire to discuss them with my BF's friends.