So the split is Lauren Alaina and Jacob Lusk on one side of the stage and James Durbin and Haley Reinhart on the other. Scotty McCreery is last, and instead of making him decide, Ryan just tells him that he is safe. Whew, so much nicer than expected. Fakeout! Ryan asks him to go stand next to the pair he thinks is safe. He says he can't, then Ryan walks him over to James and Haley and tells them they are all three safe.