Haley Reinhart is inspired by Michael Jackson's "Earth Song." Call me a cynical old bat, but sometimes songs that so specifically point out troubles in the world aren't my cup of tea. Perhaps I have a cold black heart because I don't think that listening to a song about earth falling apart is going to fix it. Yes, that's it, I have a cold black heart. So what can I say? Haley sang it nicely, with some ahhs and oohs, and she sang most of the end in a growl. Jennifer felt that Haley was inspired by her song, but she basically says that it wasn't a good song choice, especially following James. A good message is one thing, but a song that will get the audience moving is quite another. Jennifer gets some minor boos for that. Randy agrees, plus he's confused about her as an artist, and she needed more runs, and she was screaming. He was not a fan. Steven Tyler says Randy and J.Lo are wrong, so there.