5. Siobhan Magnus. (right) The good: Toned down, sophisticated, controlled, great song selection, good overall vocal, understood a HUGE note would have killed the entire thing. The bad: I had higher expectations for Siobhan. It was solid yet stagnant (perhaps having to do with the arrangement). While Casey conveyed raw emotion during a quiet song, Siobhan merely floated along, never fully connecting with the viewer. Honestly, I was going back and forth with Siobhan and Katie for the fifth spot, but after listening back to the vocals, Siobhan's were superior. Still, Siobhan is good, but once the peasants get voted off, she's going to have to be great.