Katelyn Epperly takes on Carole King's "I Feel the Earth Move." She's playing the keyboard, too. She's in key, and she's into it, but I'm kind of bored. And I'm waiting to hear that we don't know what kind of artist she is. Randy says it's a great song, but he didn't feel any connection, so it felt put on. Yes, that's exactly how I felt. Ellen says she has a great voice and a great look, but this wasn't a wow performance. "It just wasn't enough." Kara says she didn't feel like she was competing, she was just going through the motions. Katelyn says she was trying to be less corny. Simon says he likes her hair. This is going to go downhill, isn't it? He says it was kind of like request night at a restaurant if you were working there. He says it's a simple song and she didn't do much with it, so this might have been a mistake.