Haeley Vaughn is taking on a little Miley Cyrus tonight, with "The Climb." Haeley's random fact is that she likes to make things, especially hair accessories and headbands. Oh, she is so 16. Anyway, her performance is OK. She adds a little extra twang to it, but kind of inconsistently, and to my ear, she's having a fair number of pitch problems. Randy says it didn't work for him; in fact, "it was excruciating." He says she didn't connect to the song at all. Ellen tells her not to stop smiling and that she wouldn't worry about that, but she didn't feel Haeley connected to it. Kara says a lot of people at home are rooting for her and that she's a good performer, but she needs about a year of strengthening her talent. Well, bummer, they should have given her that year. Simon doesn't want to pile on, but he says it was an utter mess.