Haeley Vaughn is another Coloradoan, from Fort Collins, and she's 16. Her mom let her get her nose pierced since she made the Top 24. Her song choice is "I Wanna Hold Your Hand." At first, I think, this is a problem, it's SO the Beatles, it's just not going to work. But she starts singing, and she puts her own spin on it, and it's interesting and keeps my attention. But toward the end, she starts to wear on me. So I'm not sure what to think just yet. Kara says from a technical standpoint, there were some issues, but every time she takes the stage, she has fun and everyone feels it. Randy says she is unpredictable, which is good, but he gives her some points about trying to get the top of her notes a little clearer. Ellen says she shines on stage, especially at 16. She says she enjoyed, as someone who likes music. Simon says he thought it was verging on terrible because she was a windup doll who wouldn't stop smiling, and he thinks that was part of why the vocals were inconsistent.