Labor Day falls in the midst of a presidential campaign in which rising unemployment is a prime domestic focus. Democrats prefer to blame trade policy, while Republicans often point the finger at high oil prices. Seldom mentioned these days are automation and immigrants, although half a century ago, they were considered among the key causes of joblessness.

The Times, throughout its 127-year history, has proposed a host of solutions for unemployment. At the turn of the century, the paper's answer was straightforward: Idle hordes in Eastern cities need simply move West. The same logic applied to poverty-stricken masses in England, who needed only to board a steamer for Canada -- where at least young girls, if not Londoners, would be welcomed. Shortly after World War II, Times editorialists posited the odd theory that schools' neglect of core arts and sciences courses was creating a generation of unemployed professionals who might spread dangerous communist or Nazi ideals.

This review of Times editorials past might provide some insights into today's problems -- or just a chuckle over how much, or how little, things have changed.

June 8, 1908



No Unemployed Necessary

They are busy making hay while the sun shines in the tiers of States below the old slave line. They will be harvesting wheat there soon. In three weeks the tiers of States above the line will all be cutting hay.

For the next hundred days there will be work for every man willing and able in the United States. The best charity that could be devised in the congested centers of the East would be to send the idle out West. Kansas wants 25,000 hands for the hay and harvest time.

It would benefit those accustomed to city life to get out in the prairies and among the oak openings of the West. Some of them would never return and this would be good for the men, for the East and for the West.

California farmers are busy now with the fruit harvest and the idle in the cities can find work and good pay in the orchards.

Nov. 12, 1909

A Faulty Economic Policy

We daily hear lamentable reports of the "out-of-works" in London and other parts of the British empire, mostly in England. ...

The efforts of the government seem to be directed to providing food and shelter in a meager and unsatisfactory way for these people in such deep distress. This seems to us to be a false economy. Across the sea in the British colonies, particularly in Canada, there is easily room for the surplus working population of England to find prompt employment at good wages. In Toronto the other day an employment office informed the correspondent of a London paper that if 1,000 young women were sent to him during the coming spring months he would find work for every one of them immediately. ...

These Canadians have a horror of the average unskilled Englishman seeking employment in Canada, and of all the undesirables the Londoner is the least wanted. But when it comes to the English girl, she makes her way in Canada in a marvelous fashion.

Jan. 15, 1919



Will There Be a Sex War?

Unemployment is one of the gravest problems confronting the United States -- or, for that matter, the whole world -- during the period of reconstruction. Thousands of soldiers are being discharged daily. Wartime plants are being closed down; new peace industries have not yet taken their places. Capital is marking time, awaiting readjustments. ...