Text size: increase text sizedecrease text size
From the Los Angeles Times

MOVIE REVIEW

'Material Girls'

There's just not enough "Material" with these girls.

'Material Girls' - Aug. 18

'Material Girls' - Aug. 18
Hilary Duff and Haylie Duff star as cosmetics heiresses living in a material world who lose their inheritance when a scandal wrecks the family company. Written by John Quaintance and Jessica O’Toole. Directed by Martha Coolidge. PG for language and rude humor. (Joyce Rudolph / MGM)


Brain-numbing movies in August are as common as the hum of cicadas and tropical humidity. And, like both of those things, they can put you right to sleep.

This time around, in "Material Girls" — doesn't the title make you the teensiest bit anxious? — the tranquilizer is the Duff sister act: those lovable teens, Haylie and Hilary. They're sisters in the movie too, a pair of hyper-affected, beyond-spoiled brats who are into makeup and IMing, and flash white teeth and creamy-white-moisturized skin (Dad left them a troubled cosmetics company). Beats taking the SATs.

These celebrity wannabe/heiresses are about as chic as last year's hockey playoffs. Mom is partly to blame because she ran off to Egypt and calls herself Isis now.

Madonna's anthem was only good-naturedly arrogant, but the SoCal siblings, like the film's script, are arrogant, ghastly immature and offensive to any audience that isn't all of the above. Hilary, as Tanzie Marchetta, is at her restrained best pretending she's a hooker who gives skin-care tips to a trio of hags spending a night in the holding tank. But it's for sure that acting wasn't anyone's priorities in "Material Girls."

Overacting was. Haylie, as Ava, the older sister, doesn't shut up from start to finish. Her soon-to-be-afianced is a hunky actor who stars in a TV series called "Long Island." When the boyfriend meets a girl at a party, he asks, "You want me to sign your abs?" OMG, Haylie, dump this guy! Instead, he dumps her.

Anjelica Huston is Fabiella, the cosmetics queen who's drooling to take over the down-in-the-dumps Marchetta company. She wanders in and out of the film, spicing up her lines by employing a patois of Italian, French and German.

The dialogue doesn't improve with the arrival of Lukas Haas playing a pro-bono attorney who becomes involved with the girls to help them clear their late father's name (apparently one of Dad's creams caused problems with a lady's .... uh, let's forget that). Haas smiles, and moves his arms and legs from time to time, which indicates he's alive onscreen. He gets frustrated when Haylie backs out of a kiss because she doesn't like his cat.

"You're all frosting and no cupcake," he says.

The same could apply to "Material Girls."


'Material Girls'

MPAA rating: PG for language and rude humor.

An MGM release. Director Martha Coolidge. Writers John Quaintance, Jessica O'Toole, Amy Rardin. Director of photography Johnny E. Jensen. Editor Steven Cohen. Running time: 1 hour, 40 minutes.

In general release.

Related topic galleries: Anjelica Huston, Madonna, Martha Coolidge, Lukas Haas

Get home delivery of The Sun and save over 50% off the newsstand price

Images in the news

Day in pictures
Day in pictures | Today's Sun photos | Search
Entertainment photos | Sports photos

Caption Call
Think you're clever? Prove it. We'll post the photos, you write the captions

Celebrity breakups
Check out photos of famous couples whose relationship ended in divorce

Features

Featured Video Advertisers

THINGS TO DO
Sundaes in the Park
Finish off your week at the beach with some ice cream and live music in Northside Park.
Search events

RECENT BLOG UPDATES FROM THE BEACH LIFE

FROM B, THE PAPER
Personal anthem
What song best expresses who you are? Readers weigh in

RECENT BLOG UPDATES FROM BTHESITE.COM
FEATURED GALLERY
Weddings
Upload photos from your wedding and view those from others.

FEATURED USER
crabsandbeer
This picture was taken at the annual Fourth of July parade in Dundalk.


Reader videos | Talk forums | Trivia quizzes

Today's columnists

Columnists: News | Sports | Business | Lifestyle

About our coverage

The Sun is committed to publishing information quickly and accurately. We take our readers' concerns seriously and will promptly investigate when we are alerted to possible errors.
• To report an error, use our feedback page.
• To submit questions to Sun reporters and editors, visit Under The Sun, a blog offering insight into how decisions are made at The Sun.