Why trade Carlos Boozer for Andrea Bargnani? Bargnani never has lived up to his hype or No. 1-pick status and wouldn’t be as valuable in terms of wins to the Bulls this season. Boozer is a legitimate scoring and rebounding option. He is suspect on defense, but so is Bargnani. Scot Levine, Chicago
Yes, if people are disenchanted with Boozer’s defense, take a gander at Bargnani’s for a stretch. First of all, this trade doesn’t sound like it’s happening. Secondly, many trades in this league are done for financial reasons as much as -- if not more so -- than basketball reasons. If the Bulls agreed to this deal, there’s a chance they could drop below the luxury tax threshold, a penalty they’ve never paid in franchise history. But trading for Bargnani eliminates all future flexibility and probably would lead to the departure of Luol Deng when he becomes a free agent after the 2013-14 season. Trading Boozer also would eliminate the Bulls’ most likely option for the amnesty provision, which only can be used on players under contract on your team when the new collective bargaining agreement began. I’m still not 100 percent sure Boozer falls victim to the amnesty provision, but if he does, it would be after the 2013-14 season. Bargnani still won’t be guarding anybody then.
Do the Bulls have a justified excuse for not having enough talent around Derrick Rose to win it all? They are following the same pattern that was used around MJ. If I was Derrick Rose, no way I’d stay in Chicago if the Bulls don’t win a title before his contract is up. He’ll be another John Stockton and Karl Malone, for sure. John Coleman, Mansfield, Texas
Happy Monday, huh? The pattern used around MJ seemed to work pretty well. The Bulls also just had two players play in the All-Star Game, voted in by league coaches. Granted, Luol Deng and Joakim Noah aren’t flashy, transcendent stars like LeBron James. But they’re key pieces to a core that produced the most regular-season victories in the NBA the past two seasons. The Bulls swung for the fences to get James, trading Kirk Hinrich to Washington for nothing but salary-cap space. It didn’t work out. Their backup plan led them to a conference finals appearance and perhaps a second straight trip if injuries hadn’t claimed Rose and Noah last April in the 76ers series. If Rose didn’t get hurt, perhaps management kept that team intact and took another shot. Nothing can be judged until Rose is back. The Heat isn’t winning a title without James. Once Rose returns, a new plan to acquire another shot-creator or scorer will have to be in place. All signs point to the summer of 2014 as the next chance to judge management’s acumen.
I understand some of the cap issues the Bulls are facing in the next year or so, but given the play of Nate Robinson this season, why wouldn’t the Bulls try to lock him up through a short deal? After Rose, no other Bull really starts or comes off the bench with energy. He reminds me of Vinny “Microwave” Johnson. Joe Damato, Auburn Hills, Mich.
Funny, he reminds me of our 7-year-old, who never stops talking. Nate has incredible energy. I’ve truly never seen anything like it in a locker room. Many times this season, I’ve been interviewing an athlete on the other side of the locker room and I go to transcribe the interview and all I hear is Nate. I can only imagine what it’s like on the team buses and planes. But I digress. Nate has definitely played well many times this season. He has saved some games with his scoring ability and his floor game, particularly when he started for the injured Kirk Hinrich, has continued to progress from when he averaged a career-high in assists last season with the Warriors. That said, I think Nate has a tendency to wear people out and can serve as a distraction at times. His energy is more enthusiastic than malicious, but I’d be surprised to see him return.
I’m very impressed with Jimmy Butler. Do you see him as the future shooting guard or small forward? Jerry, North Aurora
Tom Thibodeau has said Butler is more of a small forward, but the key, obviously, is his defensive versatility. He can guard three positions, and this flexibility is critical to Thibodeau’s defensive schemes. The fascinating subplot to Butler’s development will be when Luol Deng’s deal ends after the 2013-14 season. If the Bulls use the amnesty provision on Boozer and don’t re-sign Deng, they could have salary-cap space. Of course, bringing Deng back at a reduced salary also is an option.