But by the time the final whistle sounded on a cool and overcast day in Guangzhou, China, all those years ago, the three players and their 15 teammates were on top of the world.
The final score on that memorable afternoon at Tianhe Stadium was U.S. 2, Norway 1. Soccer's first Women's World Cup saw the Americans prevail, and the party that night at the White Swan Hotel lasted well into the early morning.
Before another and altogether stylistically different U.S. team takes the field against North Korea on Tuesday in the sixth Women's World Cup — this one in Germany — today's players would do well to consider what the trailblazers accomplished.
The 91ers, as they call themselves, went on to even greater glory, winning another World Cup in 1999 and Olympic gold medals in 1996 and 2004.
But two decades have passed.
Michelle Akers, who scored the winning goal against Norway in the 1991 final and was the tournament's top scorer, now runs a rescue ranch for horses in Florida.
Carin Jennings-Gabarra, the Most Valuable Player in the 1991 tournament, has been coaching the women's team at the the Naval Academy since 1993.
Lilly might have played in her record sixth World Cup this summer but retired in January. Hamm and Foudy will be involved in Germany 2011, but as commentators for ESPN.
All five players are married and have children, and the torch has been passed to a new generation. The question is: How will it fare?
The U.S. has never finished out of the top three in World Cup or Olympic competition, but the women's game has developed significantly in the past 20 years, and while the U.S. might be ranked No. 1 in the world, just ahead of Germany and Brazil, other teams such as Norway, Sweden, North Korea, England, Japan, Canada, France and several others are fast catching up.
The 21-player U.S. roster still has ties to 1991. Coach Pia Sundhage, for example, played for Sweden in that first tournament in China, where the Swedes finished third.
Veteran defender Christie Rampone is the lone holdover from the 1999 team. She, along with midfielder Shannon Boxx and forward Abby Wambach, were on the field in 2004 when the remaining heroes of 1991 bowed out by winning Olympic gold in Greece, defeating Brazil in overtime in Athens.
But 13 of today's U.S. players are newcomers to the World Cup, and Foudy, for one, wonders how they will perform.
"The fact that you have a lot of players who haven't played in this type of atmosphere in Germany is a concern," she said during an ESPN-sponsored conference call last week.
Tony DiCicco, an assistant under then-coach Anson Dorrance in 1991 and the man who coached the U.S. to its 1996 Olympic and 1999 World Cup titles, has other worries.
"My concern with the U.S. team is it hasn't played consistently well this year," DiCicco said on the same conference call. "It has great games, and then, all of a sudden, the kind of game that seems subpar, and I'm not sure why that is."
Once almost invincible, the U.S. has been beaten by Mexico, Sweden and England in the past eight months, and there's one other worry.
"As good as the team is … one thing that I would like to add to it is more speed," DiCicco said.