That would be the obvious second-guess after a 5-for-5 performance that produced eight RBIs and an American League record 18 total bases, but it's not really so obvious at all. I suppose you could make the case for walking him with one out and nobody on in the fifth inning -- when he doubled -- but not in any of the four home run at-bats.
- Pictures: Josh Hamilton's four-homer night
- Connolly's Bar: Josh Hamilton's fourth homer one of top Camden Yards moments
- Looking back: Rocky Colavito hit 4 homers against Orioles in 1959
- Peter Schmuck grades the Orioles
- Pictures: 25 most memorable moments in Baltimore sports history
- Orioles pictures: May
See more photos »
Well, I guess Showalter could have ordered him walked when it was a blowout in the eighth, but that would have been bush league and the Orioles would have looked worse than they did giving up a piece of history.
Obviously, in retrospect, they should have walked him all five times he came to the plate, but that's just not the way you play the game.